数字技术预防痴呆或轻度认知障碍患者跌倒:系统综述的快速系统概览
该概览评估数字技术减少痴呆或轻度认知障碍患者跌倒及跌倒风险的证据,纳入7篇系统综述(含22项原始研究、1412名参与者)。所有综述在AMSTAR-2上存在严重缺陷,原始研究多为小样本、非随机、低至中等质量;仅环境传感器系统报告了对跌倒的直接影响但结论不确定,可穿戴设备与虚拟现实可能区分跌倒者,运动游戏可能改善平衡。
要点
- 证据方法学薄弱:7篇系统综述均有严重缺陷,原始研究多为小样本非随机低至中等质量。
- 仅环境传感器系统报告对跌倒的直接影响,但结论不确定。
- 可穿戴设备与虚拟现实可能区分跌倒者,运动游戏可能改善平衡。
核心结论
- 数字技术减少痴呆或轻度认知障碍患者跌倒及跌倒风险的证据方法学薄弱,基于小样本且常为间接证据。
- 需要更高质量随机对照试验提供有效性的可靠证据。
- 技术设计应纳入用户意见并考虑更广泛的实施背景。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入7篇系统综述,含22项相关原始研究、1412名 unique 参与者。
- 采用标准方法快速筛选、提取数据、评估偏倚风险与重叠并合成各类技术证据。
主要发现
- 所有综述在AMSTAR-2上存在严重缺陷;原始研究样本小、异质性大、多为非随机、评为低或中等质量。
- 评估的技术包括可穿戴传感器、环境传感器系统、运动游戏和虚拟现实系统,未发现有关应用程序的证据。
- 仅环境传感器系统报告了对跌倒的直接影响,但结论不确定。
- 可穿戴设备和虚拟现实技术有证据表明可能区分跌倒与未跌倒的痴呆患者。
- 运动游戏有证据表明可能改善平衡。
关键数值与推荐
- AMSTAR-2评估显示所有纳入综述存在严重缺陷。
- 原始研究质量多为低或中等,样本量小且异质性大。
- 环境传感器系统对跌倒直接影响的证据不确定。
- 可穿戴设备与虚拟现实可能区分跌倒者,运动游戏可能改善平衡。
临床怎么用
- 临床应谨慎解读现有数字技术预防跌倒的证据,不应过度依赖其有效性。
- 可考虑运动游戏改善平衡,但需结合个体情况并监测。
- 可穿戴设备与虚拟现实区分跌倒者的证据尚不充分,不宜作为常规筛查工具。
- 技术应用应结合用户意见和实施背景,优先选择高质量证据支持的方法。
局限性
- 纳入综述在AMSTAR-2上存在严重缺陷。
- 原始研究样本量小、异质性大、多为非随机设计、质量低或中等。
- 证据常为间接,缺乏对跌倒直接影响的可靠数据。
- 未发现有关应用程序的证据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Falls are a common cause of potentially preventable death, disability and loss of independence with an annual estimated cost of £4.4bn. People living with dementia (PlwD) or mild cognitive impairment (MCI) have an increased fall risk. This overview evaluates evidence for technologies aiming to reduce falls and fall risk for PlwD or MCI. METHODS: In October 2022, we searched five databases for evidence syntheses. We used standard methods to rapidly screen, extract data, assess risk of bias and overlap, and synthesise the evidence for each technology type. RESULTS: We included seven systematic reviews, incorporating 22 relevant primary studies with 1,412 unique participants. All reviews had critical flaws on AMSTAR-2: constituent primary studies were small, heterogeneous, mostly non-randomised and assessed as low or moderate quality. Technologies assessed were: wearable sensors, environmental sensor-based systems, exergaming, virtual reality systems. We found no evidence relating to apps. Review evidence for the direct impact on falls was available only from environmental sensors, and this was inconclusive. For wearables and virtual reality technologies there was evidence that technologies may differentiate PlwD who fell from those who did not; and for exergaming that balance may be improved. CONCLUSIONS: The evidence for technology to reduce falls and falls risk for PlwD and MCI is methodologically weak, based on small numbers of participants and often indirect. There is a need for higher-quality RCTs to provide robust evidence for effectiveness of fall prevention technologies. Such technologies should be designed with input from users and consideration of the wider implementation context.
引用
- Eost-Telling C, Yang Y, Norman G, et al. Digital technologies to prevent falls in people living with dementia or mild cognitive impairment: a rapid systematic overview of systematic reviews. Age Ageing. 2024. PMID: 38219225. doi:10.1093/ageing/afad238
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。