机器学习方法提升初级保健老年人跌倒风险筛查的准确性与效率
该研究利用整合医疗系统16家成员机构的患者临床数据,开展病例对照研究,开发并评估基于电子健康记录(EHR)的机器学习模型预测老年人跌倒相关损伤,并与常用跌倒风险筛查问卷比较。结果显示问卷筛查的AUC最高仅0.59,而EHR机器学习模型最佳AUROC达0.76,6个月与1年预测性能相似。结论认为机器学习跌倒损伤预测方法准确性更优,可释放临床时间用于启动个性化跌倒预防干预。
要点
- 常用跌倒风险筛查问卷AUC最高仅0.59,且三个问题间相似度为23%至33%。
- 基于EHR的机器学习模型最佳AUROC为0.76,6个月与1年预测性能相似。
- 机器学习方法可更准确预测跌倒损伤风险,并释放临床时间用于个性化预防。
核心结论
- 当前基于问卷的老年人跌倒风险筛查方法准确性欠佳、条目冗余且未与预防措施联动。
- 机器学习跌倒损伤预测方法能更准确预测风险并具有更优敏感性,同时释放临床时间用于启动个性化跌倒预防干预。
研究设计与样本
- 利用整合医疗系统16家成员机构的患者层面临床数据开展病例对照研究,开发并评估老年人跌倒相关损伤预测模型。
- 评估基于常用跌倒风险筛查工具中三个问题的问卷预测,并利用常规可用的纵向EHR数据开发四个时间机器学习模型预测未来跌倒损伤风险。
- 开发跌倒损伤预防临床决策支持(CDS)实施原型,将预防干预与患者特异性跌倒损伤风险因素关联。
主要发现
- 问卷-based风险筛查的受试者工作特征曲线下面积(AUC)最高达0.59,三个跌倒损伤筛查问题每对之间相似度为23%至33%。
- 基于EHR的机器学习风险筛查性能显著提升,最佳AUROC为0.76,6个月与1年预测模型预测性能相似。
关键数值与推荐
- 问卷-based风险筛查AUC最高0.59,三个问题每对相似度23%至33%。
- EHR机器学习模型最佳AUROC为0.76,6个月与1年预测模型性能相似。
临床怎么用
- 在初级保健中可采用基于EHR的机器学习工具识别跌倒损伤高风险老年人,以弥补问卷筛查准确性不足。
- 可将机器学习风险预测与临床决策支持原型结合,针对患者特异性风险因素启动个性化跌倒预防干预。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: While many falls are preventable, they remain a leading cause of injury and death in older adults. Primary care clinics largely rely on screening questionnaires to identify people at risk of falls. Limitations of standard fall risk screening questionnaires include suboptimal accuracy, missing data, and non-standard formats, which hinder early identification of risk and prevention of fall injury. We used machine learning methods to develop and evaluate electronic health record (EHR)-based tools to identify older adults at risk of fall-related injuries in a primary care population and compared this approach to standard fall screening questionnaires. METHODS: Using patient-level clinical data from an integrated healthcare system consisting of 16-member institutions, we conducted a case-control study to develop and evaluate prediction models for fall-related injuries in older adults. Questionnaire-derived prediction with three questions from a commonly used fall risk screening tool was evaluated. We then developed four temporal machine learning models using routinely available longitudinal EHR data to predict the future risk of fall injury. We also developed a fall injury-prevention clinical decision support (CDS) implementation prototype to link preventative interventions to patient-specific fall injury risk factors. RESULTS: Questionnaire-based risk screening achieved area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) up to 0.59 with 23% to 33% similarity for each pair of three fall injury screening questions. EHR-based machine learning risk screening showed significantly improved performance (best AUROC = 0.76), with similar prediction performance between 6-month and one-year prediction models. CONCLUSIONS: The current method of questionnaire-based fall risk screening of older adults is suboptimal with redundant items, inadequate precision, and no linkage to prevention. A machine learning fall injury prediction method can accurately predict risk with superior sensitivity while freeing up clinical time for initiating personalized fall prevention interventions. The developed algorithm and data science pipeline can impact routine primary care fall prevention practice.
引用
- Song W, Latham NK, Liu L, et al. Improved accuracy and efficiency of primary care fall risk screening of older adults using a machine learning approach. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2024. PMID: 38217355. doi:10.1111/jgs.18776
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。