D3-肌酸稀释法估算肌肉量:临床意义及与其他方法比较的叙述性综述
本文为叙述性综述,检索PubMed/MEDLINE和Web of Science截至2023年9月使用D3-肌酸稀释法测量成年人肌肉量的研究,共纳入23项。D3-肌酸估算的肌肉量与死亡、移动障碍、跌倒和骨折呈较一致关联,与肌肉力量和成分关联不一致;与MRI强正相关但存在低估或高估。
要点
- D3-肌酸稀释法估算的肌肉量与跌倒和骨折、移动障碍及死亡呈较一致关联。
- D3-肌酸稀释法与MRI测量肌肉量呈强正相关,但可能存在低估或高估。
- 与肌肉力量、肌肉成分和身体表现的关联性不一致,需谨慎解读。
核心结论
- D3-肌酸稀释法估算的肌肉量可能是临床结局的有价值预测指标,与跌倒和骨折、移动障碍及死亡呈较一致关联。
- 与肌肉力量、肌肉成分和身体表现的关联较不一致,且与MRI测量相比可能存在低估或高估。
研究设计与样本
- 叙述性综述,检索PubMed/MEDLINE和Web of Science从建库至2023年9月使用D3-肌酸稀释法测量成年人(≥18岁)肌肉的研究,共纳入23项研究。
主要发现
- 23项研究中15项探讨D3-肌酸稀释法与临床结局的关联,报告与死亡(100%,n=2)、移动障碍(100%,n=5)、跌倒和骨折(100%,n=3)的关联较一致。
- 与身体表现(63.3%,n=11)、肌肉力量(44.4%,n=9)和肌肉成分(33.3%,n=3)的关联一致性较低,且存在矛盾结果。
- 14项研究比较D3-肌酸稀释法与包括MRI在内的其他体成分技术,D3-肌酸稀释法与MRI呈强正相关,但测量值差异范围为较MRI低0.62 kg至高超13.47 kg。
关键数值与推荐
- 与死亡关联的研究中100%(n=2)报告一致关联。
- 与移动障碍关联的研究中100%(n=5)报告一致关联。
- 与跌倒和骨折关联的研究中100%(n=3)报告一致关联。
- 与身体表现关联的研究中63.3%(n=11)报告一致关联。
- 与肌肉力量关联的研究中44.4%(n=9)报告一致关联;与肌肉成分关联的研究中33.3%(n=3)报告一致关联。
临床怎么用
- D3-肌酸稀释法估算的肌肉量可用于评估跌倒和骨折、移动障碍及死亡风险,但解读肌肉力量和身体表现关联时需谨慎。
- 临床应用中需注意D3-肌酸稀释法与MRI测量值可能存在低估或高估,不宜直接互换。
局限性
- 本文为叙述性综述,未报告系统评价方法学细节如偏倚风险评估和证据质量分级。
- 部分临床结局关联的研究数量较少(如死亡n=2、跌倒和骨折n=3),且存在矛盾结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The D3-creatine (D3-Cr) dilution method is of emerging interest for estimating total-body skeletal muscle mass. This review explores the association of muscle mass estimated via D3-Cr with various clinical outcomes and provides a summary of the literature comparing D3-Cr with other body composition techniques. METHODS: A literature search was conducted on PubMed/MEDLINE and Web of Science for studies using D3-Cr to measure muscle in adult populations (ie, ≥18 years old) from inception until September 2023. RESULTS: Out of the 23 included studies, 15 investigated the correlation between D3-Cr and clinical outcomes. More consistent associations were reported for mortality (100%, n = 2), mobility disability (100%; n = 5), falls and fractures (100%; n = 3), physical performance (63.3%; n = 11), muscle strength (44.4%; n = 9), and muscle composition (33.3%; n = 3). However, conflicting findings were also reported for such correlations. Among the 23 studies, 14 compared D3-Cr-estimated muscle with other body composition techniques, including magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) as a reference method. Strong and positive correlations were found between D3-Cr and MRI. Nonetheless, variations in muscle measurements were noted, with differences in D3-Cr values ranging from 0.62 kg lower to 13.47 kg higher compared to MRI. CONCLUSIONS: D3-Cr-estimated muscle mass may be a valuable predictor of clinical outcomes showing consistent associations with falls and fractures, mobility disability, and mortality. However, less consistent associations were found with muscle strength and composition, and physical performance. Although a strong correlation exists between D3-Cr-estimated muscle mass and MRI measurements, under- or overestimation may occur.
引用
- Pagano AP, Montenegro J, Oliveira CLP, et al. Estimating Muscle Mass Using D3-Creatine Dilution: A Narrative Review of Clinical Implications and Comparison With Other Methods. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2024. PMID: 38135279. doi:10.1093/gerona/glad280
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。