VA养老院与社区养老院临终关怀质量比较
本研究基于VA电子病历与丧亲家庭调查(BFS)全国数据,回顾性比较2021年10月至2022年3月在VA社区生活中心(CLC)或VA签约社区养老院(CNH)接受临终关怀的退伍军人家庭对临终照护质量的评分。最终样本为1238名退伍军人(CLC n=1012,CNH n=226)。结果显示,CLC组家庭对临终整体照护给出最高评分(9或10分/10分)的调整后比例较CNH组高出13个百分点以上,特定临终照护领域差距更大。
要点
- VA养老院临终关怀的家庭整体照护最高评分比例较社区养老院高13个百分点以上。
- 特定临终照护领域(症状管理、沟通、情感支持等)的质量差距更大。
- 社区养老院临终关怀质量存在不足,需政策与实践干预改进。
核心结论
- VA社区生活中心接受临终关怀的退伍军人家庭对临终整体照护的最高评分比例显著高于VA签约社区养老院。
- 社区养老院临终关怀在多个特定照护领域存在更大质量差距,需紧急干预改进。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析VA全国电子病历与丧亲家庭调查(BFS)数据,纳入2021年10月至2022年3月在VA社区生活中心或VA签约社区养老院接受临终关怀并死亡的退伍军人,最终样本1238名(CLC n=1012,CNH n=226),由近亲完成BFS。
主要发现
- 家庭对临终整体照护给出最高评分(9或10分/10分)的调整后比例,CLC组较CNH组高13个百分点以上。
- 特定临终照护领域(症状管理、沟通、情感与精神支持、丧葬与遗属福利信息)的质量差距更大。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要结局为BFS对生命最后30天所接受照护的全局评分,最高评分为9或10分(满分10分)。
- 次要结局包括BFS中症状管理、沟通、情感与精神支持、丧葬与遗属福利信息相关条目。
临床怎么用
- 老年医学科医生应关注社区养老院临终关怀质量,参考VA养老院模式加强症状管理、沟通与情感支持。
- 对在社区养老院接受临终关怀的退伍军人,可主动评估照护质量并推动政策与实践改进。
局限性
- 本研究为回顾性分析,仅纳入完成BFS的近亲,可能存在选择偏倚。
- 样本中CNH组人数(226)远少于CLC组(1012),可能影响比较的精确性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: While the Veterans Health Administration (VA) has long provided hospice care within VA community living centers (CLCs, i.e., VA nursing homes), an increasing number of Veterans are receiving hospice in VA-contracted community nursing homes (CNHs). However, little data exist about the quality of end-of-life (EOL) care provided in CNHs. The aim of this study was to compare family ratings of the quality of EOL care provided to Veterans receiving hospice in VA CLCs and VA-contracted CNHs. METHODS: We conducted a retrospective analysis of national data from VA's electronic medical record and Bereaved Family Survey (BFS) for Veterans who received hospice in VA CLCs or VA-contracted CNHs between October 2021 and March 2022. The final sample included 1238 Veterans who died in either a CLC (n = 1012) or a CNH (n = 226) and whose next-of-kin completed the BFS. Our primary outcome was the BFS global rating of care received in the last 30 days of life. Secondary outcomes included BFS items related to symptom management, communication, emotional and spiritual support, and information about burial and survivor benefits. We compared unadjusted and adjusted proportions for all BFS outcomes between those who received hospice in CLCs and CNHs. RESULTS: The adjusted proportion of family members who gave the best possible rating (a score of 9 or 10 out of a possible 10) for the overall care received near EOL was more than 13 percentage points higher for Veterans who received hospice in VA CLCs compared to VA-contracted CNHs. Our findings also revealed quality gaps of even greater magnitude in specific EOL care-focused domains. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings document inadequacies in the quality of multiple aspects of EOL care provided to Veterans in CNH-based hospice and illuminate the urgent need for policy and practice interventions to improve this care.
引用
- Wachterman MW, Smith D, Carpenter JG, et al. A comparison of end-of-life care quality for Veterans receiving hospice in VA nursing homes and community nursing homes. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2023. PMID: 37947240. doi:10.1111/jgs.18606
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。