整体评估干预对多病共存与衰弱成人的效果:系统综述总览
该总览纳入29篇系统综述(14篇含荟萃分析),评估整体评估干预(HABIs)对社区多病共存或衰弱成人的效果。不同干预类型、场景和结局证据不一致;医院CGA对减少养老院入住、维持患者居家生存证据最佳,社区CGA对住院和跨场景CGA对HRQoL有一定获益证据。
要点
- 医院CGA对减少养老院入住、维持患者居家生存证据最佳。
- 社区CGA对住院、跨场景CGA对HRQoL有一定获益证据。
- 医院HABIs对HRQoL和急诊再就诊、社区HABIs对总体医疗利用等无获益证据。
核心结论
- HABIs对不同类型干预、场景和结局的效果证据总体不一致,医院CGA在减少养老院入住和维持居家生存方面证据最佳。
研究设计与样本
- 伞形综述,检索8个数据库,筛查9803条题录后纳入29篇系统综述(14篇含荟萃分析),报告14类HABIs。
主要发现
- 医院HABIs对健康相关生活质量(HRQoL)和急诊再就诊无获益证据。
- 社区HABIs对总体医疗利用 rate、急诊就诊、养老院入住和死亡率无获益证据。
- 医院综合老年评估(CGA)对减少养老院入住、维持患者居家生存证据最佳。
- 社区CGA对住院、跨社区与医院场景的CGA对HRQoL有一定获益证据。
- 以患者为中心的医疗之家对HRQoL、心理健康、自我管理和住院有获益。
临床怎么用
- 对社区多病共存或衰弱成人,可优先考虑医院CGA以降低养老院入住并维持居家。
- 社区CGA可能有助于减少住院,跨场景CGA可能改善HRQoL。
- 以患者为中心的医疗之家可能改善HRQoL、心理健康、自我管理和住院。
局限性
- 证据在不同干预类型、场景和结局间不一致,原文未报告具体异质性或偏倚评估数值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Holistic assessment-based interventions (HABIs) are effective in older people admitted to hospital, but it is unclear whether similar interventions are effective in adults with multiple long-term conditions or frailty in the community. We conducted an umbrella review to comprehensively evaluate the literature on HABIs for adults (aged ≥18 years) with multiple long-term conditions, and frailty. We searched eight databases for systematic reviews reporting on experimental or quasi-experimental studies. Of 9803 titles screened, we identified 29 eligible reviews (14 with meta-analysis) reporting on 14 types of HABIs. The evidence for the effectiveness of HABIs was largely inconsistent across different types of interventions, settings, and outcomes. We found evidence of no benefit from hospital HABIs on health-related quality of life (HRQoL) and emergency department re-attendance, and evidence of no benefit from community HABIs on overall health-care utilisation rates, emergency department attendance, nursing home admissions, and mortality. The best evidence of effectiveness was for hospital comprehensive geriatric assessment (CGA) on nursing home admissions, keeping patients alive and in their own homes. There was some evidence of benefit from community CGA on hospital admissions, and from CGA spanning community and hospital settings on HRQoL. Patient-centred medical homes had beneficial effects on HRQoL, mental health, self-management, and hospital admissions.
引用
- Arakelyan S, Mikula-Noble N, Ho L, et al. Effectiveness of holistic assessment-based interventions for adults with multiple long-term conditions and frailty: an umbrella review of systematic reviews. Lancet Healthy Longev. 2023. PMID: 37924844. doi:10.1016/S2666-7568(23)00190-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。