社区安宁疗护项目组成部分有效性的系统综述
本系统混合研究综述依据PRISMA指南、注册于PROSPERO(ID # CRD42022302305),检索四个数据库(CINAHL、Web of Science、ProQuest Federated及含MEDLINE的PubMed)并追溯纳入文献的参考文献,共纳入57篇文献(21篇定性、25篇定量、11篇混合方法),评估社区安宁疗护项目中单一具体组成部分的有效性,发现标准化会议(跨学科患者讨论)、志愿者参与和早期干预有助于项目成功。
要点
- 标准化跨学科会议、志愿者参与和早期干预是促进社区安宁疗护项目成功的组成部分。
- 纳入研究常用结局包括患者/照护者满意度、住院利用和居家死亡。
- 作者建议在中低收入国家及低收入、边缘化种族或族裔等关键脆弱人群中更多实施和检验这些组成部分。
核心结论
- 社区安宁疗护项目的某些组成部分是有效的,标准化会议、志愿者参与和早期干预有助于项目成功。
- 这些有效组成部分应更多在中低收入国家及关键脆弱人群中实施和检验。
- 还需对单个项目组成部分的成本效益开展更多研究。
研究设计与样本
- 系统混合研究综述,依据PRISMA指南综合定量、定性及混合方法研究结果,PROSPERO注册号ID # CRD42022302305。
- 2021年8月检索CINAHL、Web of Science、ProQuest Federated及含MEDLINE的PubMed四个数据库,并细查纳入文献的参考文献。
- 纳入标准要求评估社区安宁疗护项目中的单一具体组成部分,可在一个项目内或跨多个项目。
- 共识别1,674篇文献,57篇符合纳入标准:21篇定性、25篇定量、11篇混合方法。
主要发现
- 纳入研究一致考察的结局指标包括患者/照护者满意度、住院利用和居家死亡。
- 标准化会议(跨学科患者讨论)、志愿者参与和早期干预这三个组成部分促进了社区安宁疗护项目的成功。
临床怎么用
- 在社区安宁疗护项目中可考虑纳入标准化跨学科患者讨论会议、志愿者参与和早期干预等组成部分。
- 上述组成部分宜在中低收入国家及关键脆弱人群中进一步实施和检验。
局限性
- 原文未报告纳入研究的偏倚风险或质量评价结果。
- 原文指出单个项目组成部分的成本效益研究仍不足。
- 原文指出中低收入国家及关键脆弱人群的相关证据有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There is evidence that community-based palliative care programmes can improve patient outcomes and caregiver experiences cost-effectively. However, little is known about which specific components within these programmes contribute to improving the outcomes. AIM: To systematically review research that evaluates the effectiveness of community-based palliative care components. DESIGN: A systematic mixed studies review synthesising quantitative, qualitative and mixed-methods study findings using Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. PROSPERO: ID # CRD42022302305. DATA SOURCES: Four databases were searched in August 2021 (CINAHL, Web of Science, ProQuest Federated and PubMed including MEDLINE) and a close review of included article references. Inclusion criteria required articles to evaluate a single, specific component of a community-based palliative care programme either within an individual programme or across several programmes. RESULTS: Overall, a total of 1,674 articles were identified, with 57 meeting the inclusion criteria. Of the included studies, 21 were qualitative, 25 were quantitative and 11 had mixed methods. Outcome measures consistently examined included patient/caregiver satisfaction, hospital utilisation and home deaths. The components of standardised sessions (interdisciplinary meetings about patients), volunteer engagement and early intervention contributed to the success of community-based palliative care programmes. CONCLUSIONS: Certain components of community-based palliative care programmes are effective. Such components should be implemented and tested more in low- and middle-income countries and key and vulnerable populations such as lower-income and marginalised racial or ethnic groups. In addition, more research is needed on the cost-effectiveness of individual programme components.
引用
- Hughes MC, Vernon E, Hainstock A, et al. The effectiveness of community-based palliative care programme components: a systematic review. Age Ageing. 2023. PMID: 37740895. doi:10.1093/ageing/afad175
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。