痴呆患者功能活动与幸福感改善的促进与阻碍因素:PrAISED过程评价质性研究
该研究对PrAISED随机对照试验进行过程评价,通过88次访谈(44名痴呆患者、39名照护者)和69次治疗师访谈,探讨为何运动与功能活动干预未产生可测量的健康获益。结果显示,认知障碍、慢性躯体疾病、监督递减及COVID-19大流行为主要阻碍因素,而目标进展感知、治疗师技能与融洽关系、照护者支持为促进因素。
要点
- 认知障碍阻碍独立参与和会话间技能迁移,是核心阻碍因素。
- 治疗师技能与融洽关系、照护者支持是达成积极结局的关键促进因素。
- 监督递减策略在痴呆情境中可能不适用,自我导向干预需谨慎。
核心结论
- 自我导向干预在痴呆情境中可能不适用,即使在轻度阶段亦然。
- 认知障碍、多病共存和衰弱的影响超过了干预的任何积极效应。
- 功能能力的维持受到重视,但面对疾病不可避免的进展,其他非 tangible 结局变得重要,挑战了「健康获益」和试验结局的框架。
研究设计与样本
- 过程评价采用质性方法,包括访谈和研究者笔记。
- 数据在参与者家中或通过电话/视频会议远程收集。
- 共对44名痴呆患者(干预组n=32;对照组n=12)和39名照护者进行88次访谈,并对26名治疗师进行69次访谈。
主要发现
- 参与者重视干预主动处理其关注的健康问题,并作为社会接触、互动、信息和建议的来源。
- 达成积极结局的促进因素包括:感知到朝期望目标进展、积极期望、治疗师技能及与参与者的融洽关系、照护者支持。
- 阻碍因素包括:认知障碍(阻碍独立参与和会话间迁移)、慢性躯体健康问题和间发急性疾病与损伤、「递减」(渐进性减少监督以帮助养成习惯和独立活动)以及COVID-19大流行。
临床怎么用
- 在痴呆患者中实施功能活动干预时,应评估认知障碍程度并调整监督策略,避免过早递减监督。
- 应重视治疗师与参与者的融洽关系及照护者支持,将其作为干预成功的关键要素。
- 对多病共存和衰弱患者,需管理慢性躯体疾病和急性事件对干预参与的影响。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The PRomoting Activity, Independence and Stability in Early Dementia (PrAISED) study delivered an exercise and functional activity programme to participants living with dementia. A Randomised Controlled Trial showed no measurable benefits in activities of daily living, physical activity or quality of life. OBJECTIVE: To explore participants' responses to PrAISED and explain why an intervention that might be expected to have produced measurable health gains did not do so. METHODS: A process evaluation using qualitative methods, comprising interviews and researcher notes. SETTING: Data were collected in participants' homes or remotely by telephone or videoconferencing. SAMPLE: A total of 88 interviews were conducted with 44 participants living with dementia (n = 32 intervention group; n = 12 control group) and 39 caregivers. A total of 69 interviews were conducted with 26 therapists. RESULTS: Participants valued the intervention as proactively addressing health issues that were of concern to them, and as a source of social contact, interaction, information and advice. Facilitators to achieving positive outcomes included perceiving progress towards desired goals, positive expectations, therapists' skills and rapport with participants, and caregiver support. Barriers included: cognitive impairment, which prevented independent engagement and carry-over between sessions; chronic physical health problems and intercurrent acute illness and injury; 'tapering' (progressively infrequent supervision intended to help develop habits and independent activity); and the COVID-19 pandemic. CONCLUSIONS: Self-directed interventions may not be appropriate in the context of dementia, even in the mild stages of the condition. Dementia-specific factors affected outcomes including caregiver support, rapport with therapists, availability of supervision, motivational factors and the limitations of remote delivery. The effects of cognitive impairment, multimorbidity and frailty overwhelmed any positive impact of the intervention. Maintenance of functional ability is valued, but in the face of inevitable progression of disease, other less tangible outcomes become important, challenging how we frame 'health gain' and trial outcomes.
引用
- Di Lorito C, van der Wardt V, Pollock K, et al. The facilitators and barriers to improving functional activity and wellbeing in people with dementia: a qualitative study from the process evaluation of Promoting Activity, Independence and Stability in Early Dementia (PrAISED). Age Ageing. 2023. PMID: 37603841. doi:10.1093/ageing/afad166
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。