黑人与白人代理人对养老院晚期痴呆照护体验与认知的质性研究
ADVANCE研究为多站点质性研究,纳入14家养老院、44名晚期痴呆住民的黑人与白人代理人,探讨影响照护强度差异的认知与体验。研究发现低照护强度机构的代理人更常报告曾与住民讨论临终意愿且与提供者沟通更好;黑人代理人对管饲和心肺复苏存在较多误解;宗教与灵性信仰并非种族差异的主要驱动因素。
要点
- 低照护强度机构的黑人与白人代理人均更常报告既往与住民讨论过临终照护意愿。
- 黑人代理人对晚期痴呆临床病程及管饲、心肺复苏等治疗有效性持有较多误解。
- 宗教与灵性信仰在种族间提及频率低且相似,不支持其驱动照护差异的假设。
核心结论
- 研究反驳了宗教与灵性信仰是晚期痴呆照护种族差异驱动因素的常见假设,并揭示若干可操作的机构层面因素。
研究设计与样本
- ADVANCE为多站点质性研究,纳入来自4个医院转诊区域的14家养老院,依据管饲率和住院转院率选取照护强度不同的机构。
- 共访谈44名晚期痴呆住民的黑人与白人代理人,数据收集时间为2018年6月1日至2021年7月31日。
- 采用框架分析在预设领域内提炼主题与子主题,并用矩阵分析比较不同种族代理人的异同。
主要发现
- 44名代理人中19名(43.1%)为黑人,36名(81.8%)为女性,26名(59.0%)为住民的成年子女。
- 在照护强度最低的机构中,黑人与白人代理人均一致报告曾与住民就临终照护意愿进行过对话,且与提供者沟通总体更好。
- 黑人代理人对晚期痴呆临床病程及治疗选项(尤其是管饲和心肺复苏)的有效性持有许多误解。
- 黑人与白人代理人均描述了对养老院工作人员的不信任,但针对的工作人员角色不同。
- 宗教与灵性信仰常被认为可解释黑人住民更倾向高强度照护,但两类代理人提及均少且频率相似。
临床怎么用
- 研究识别出若干可操作的机构层面因素,可能有助于减少晚期痴呆照护的种族差异。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Regional, facility, and racial variability in intensity of care provided to nursing home (NH) residents with advanced dementia is poorly understood. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Assessment of Disparities and Variation for Alzheimer's disease NH Care at End of life (ADVANCE) is a multisite qualitative study of 14 NHs from four hospital referral regions providing varied intensity of advanced dementia care based on tube-feeding and hospital transfer rates. This report explored the perceptions and experiences of Black and White proxies (N = 44) of residents with advanced dementia to elucidate factors driving these variations. Framework analyses revealed themes and subthemes within the following a priori domains: understanding of advanced dementia and care decisions, preferences related to end-of-life care, advance care planning, decision-making about managing feeding problems and acute illness, communication and trust in NH providers, support, and spirituality in decision-making. Matrix analyses explored similarities/differences by proxy race. Data were collected from June 1, 2018 to July 31, 2021. RESULTS: Among 44 proxies interviewed, 19 (43.1%) were Black, 36 (81.8%) were female, and 26 (59.0%) were adult children of residents. In facilities with the lowest intensity of care, Black and White proxies consistently reported having had previous conversations with residents about wishes for end-of-life care and generally better communication with providers. Black proxies held numerous misconceptions about the clinical course of advanced dementia and effectiveness of treatment options, notably tube-feeding and cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Black and White proxies described mistrust of NH staff but did so towards different staffing roles. Religious and spiritual beliefs commonly thought to underlie preferences for more intense care among Black residents, were rarely, but equally mentioned by race. CONCLUSIONS: This report refuted commonly held assumptions about religiosity and spirituality as drivers of racial variations in advanced dementia care and revealed several actionable facility-level factors, which may help reduce these variations.
引用
- McCarthy EP, Lopez RP, Hendricksen M, et al. Black and white proxy experiences and perceptions that influence advanced dementia care in nursing homes: The ADVANCE study. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2023. PMID: 36856071. doi:10.1111/jgs.18303
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。