全科医生主导的改良老年综合评估对衰弱患者的影响
在苏格兰一家全科诊所,对中度至重度衰弱患者(电子衰弱指数评分>0.24)实施由全科医生主导的改良老年综合评估(MidMed),并与等待入组者比较。结果显示MidMed组非计划入院和急诊就诊风险更低、初级保健使用更多、照护连续性更好,门诊就诊和死亡率无差异。作者认为需要更长期评估和随机对照试验。
要点
- MidMed组因超过1次入院的风险低于非MidMed组(aRR 0.46,95%CI 0.30-0.71)。
- MidMed组照护连续性优于非MidMed组(UPC 0.77 vs 0.41,P<0.001)。
- 门诊就诊和死亡率两组无差异,作者认为需更长期评估和随机对照试验。
核心结论
- 这项由全科医生主导的衰弱患者服务与较低的再入院/急诊再就诊风险、更多的初级保健使用和更好的照护连续性相关。
- 作者认为需要对新型初级保健衰弱服务进行更详细的评估,覆盖更长时间段,包括稳健的随机对照试验。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入苏格兰Newbattle医疗诊所中电子衰弱指数评分>0.24的中度至重度衰弱患者,比较入组MidMed干预者与等待入组者(非MidMed)。
- MidMed由一名额外的全科医生执行改良老年综合评估并可直接预约接诊。
- 共纳入510例患者:MidMed组290例(平均(SD)年龄80.1(7.6)岁;女性59.6%),非MidMed组220例(75.4(8.6)岁;女性57.7%)。
- 中位随访396天,采用回归模型调整人口学特征和医疗使用史,估计MidMed相对非MidMed的调整率比(aRR)。
主要发现
- >1次入院的aRR(95%CI)为0.46(0.30-0.71),MidMed组低于非MidMed组。
- >1次急诊就诊的aRR(95%CI)为0.62(0.41-0.95),MidMed组低于非MidMed组。
- 初级保健使用的aRR(95%CI)为1.52(1.30-1.75),MidMed组高于非MidMed组。
- 门诊预约和死亡率两组无差异。
- 照护连续性MidMed组更好:MidMed组UPC 0.77(SD 0.19) vs 非MidMed组0.41(0.18),P < 0.001。
关键数值与推荐
- 入组条件为电子衰弱指数评分>0.24。
- >1次入院aRR 0.46(95%CI 0.30-0.71)。
- >1次急诊就诊aRR 0.62(95%CI 0.41-0.95)。
- 初级保健使用aRR 1.52(95%CI 1.30-1.75)。
- 照护连续性UPC:MidMed组0.77(SD 0.19) vs 非MidMed组0.41(0.18),P < 0.001。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论指出该全科医生主导的衰弱患者服务与较低再入院/急诊再就诊风险、更多初级保健使用和更好照护连续性相关。
- 作者认为需要对新型初级保健衰弱服务进行更详细评估,覆盖更长时间段,包括稳健的随机对照试验。
局限性
- 作者认为需要对新型初级保健衰弱服务进行更详细评估,覆盖更长时间段,包括稳健的随机对照试验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: the identification and management of frailty occurs mostly in primary care. Several different models of care exist. This study aimed to assess the impact of a new General Practitioner (GP)-led modified Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment (CGA) on service delivery, healthcare utilisation and patient outcomes. METHOD: patients with moderate-severe frailty (electronic Frailty Index score > 0.24) in Newbattle Medical Practice, Scotland, were eligible for a novel intervention (MidMed) in which an additional GP performed a modified CGA and was directly accessible for appointments. The recruits to the intervention (MidMed) group were compared with those waiting to be enrolled (non-MidMed). Outcomes included unscheduled hospital admissions, primary care consultations, continuity of care (Usual Provider of Care (UPC) index), outpatient attendances and mortality. Adjusted rate ratios (aRR), for MidMed compared to non-MidMed, were estimated using regression models adjusting for demographics and healthcare utilisation histories. RESULTS: 510 patients were included: 290 MidMed (mean(SD) age 80.1(7.6)years; 59.6% female) and 220 non-MidMed (75.4(8.6)years; 57.7% female). Median follow-up was 396 days. aRR(95%CI) was 0.46(0.30-0.71) for >1 admission, 0.62(0.41-0.95) >1 Emergency Department (ED) attendance and 1.52(1.30-1.75) for use of primary care, with no difference in outpatient appointments or mortality. Continuity of care was better for the MidMed group (MidMed UPC 0.77(SD 0.19), non-MidMed 0.41(0.18), P < 0.001). CONCLUSION: this GP-led service for frail patients was associated with lower risk of hospital readmission/ED reattendance, greater use of primary care and improved continuity of care. More detailed evaluation of novel primary care frailty services, over longer time-periods, including robust randomised controlled trials, are needed.
引用
- Jones HE, Anand A, Morrison I, et al. Impact of MidMed, a general practitioner-led modified comprehensive geriatric assessment for patients with frailty. Age Ageing. 2023. PMID: 36947740. doi:10.1093/ageing/afad006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。