基于德国国家队列20万成人握力值与低握力切点:与EWGSOP2切点的比较
该研究基于200,389名19-75岁德国国家队列(NAKO)参与者推导男女性低握力切点(峰值均值-2.5×SD),并在1,012名65-93岁KORA-Age参与者中计算低握力年龄标化患病率及全因死亡的时间依赖灵敏度和特异度。NAKO推导切点为男性29 kg、女性18 kg,比EWGSOP2切点高2 kg;NAKO切点下低握力年龄标化患病率17.7%,约为EWGSOP2切点11.7%的1.5倍,且对全因死亡灵敏度更高、特异度更低。
要点
- NAKO推导的低握力切点为男性29 kg、女性18 kg,比EWGSOP2切点高2 kg。
- NAKO切点下低握力年龄标化患病率17.7%,约为EWGSOP2切点11.7%的1.5倍。
- NAKO切点对全因死亡灵敏度更高、特异度更低,可能使更多风险患者被建议干预。
核心结论
- 基于德国人群数据的低握力切点比EWGSOP2切点高2 kg。
- 较高切点提高灵敏度,使更多风险患者被建议干预,但部分个体可能接受非急需的额外诊疗。
- 尚需研究不同切点定义的低握力患者中干预的有效性。
研究设计与样本
- 基于200,389名19-75岁德国国家队列(NAKO)参与者评估握力随年龄分布并推导男女性低握力切点(峰值均值-2.5×SD)。
- 在1,012名65-93岁KORA-Age参与者中计算低握力年龄标化患病率及全因死亡的时间依赖灵敏度和特异度。
主要发现
- 握力在生命第三和第四个十年增加,之后下降。
- NAKO推导的低握力切点为男性29 kg、女性18 kg。
- KORA-Age中NAKO切点下低握力年龄标化患病率为17.7%,EWGSOP2切点为11.7%,前者为后者的1.5倍。
- NAKO推导切点对全因死亡灵敏度更高、特异度更低。
关键数值与推荐
- NAKO推导低握力切点:男性29 kg,女性18 kg(峰值均值-2.5×SD)。
- EWGSOP2切点比NAKO推导切点低2 kg。
- KORA-Age中低握力年龄标化患病率:NAKO切点17.7%,EWGSOP2切点11.7%。
临床怎么用
- 老年医学科评估肌少症时需注意,采用NAKO推导切点(男29 kg、女18 kg)比EWGSOP2切点会识别更多低握力患者。
- 较高切点提高对全因死亡的灵敏度,有利于筛出更多风险患者进行干预,但特异度降低可能增加非急需的额外诊疗。
- 选择切点时应结合临床目的权衡灵敏度与特异度,并关注不同切点定义患者的干预有效性证据尚不充分。
局限性
- 原文未报告NAKO推导切点与EWGSOP2切点对全因死亡灵敏度和特异度的具体数值。
- 原文未报告KORA-Age中全因死亡分析的随访时间、事件数或置信区间。
- 原文指出尚需研究不同切点定义的低握力患者中干预的有效性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The European Working Group on Sarcopenia in Older People (EWGSOP) updated in 2018 the cut-off points for low grip strength to assess sarcopenia based on pooled data from 12 British studies. OBJECTIVE: Comparison of the EWGSOP2 cut-off points for low grip strength to those derived from a large German sample. METHODS: We assessed the grip strength distribution across age and derived low grip strength cut-off points for men and women (peak mean -2.5 × SD) based on 200,389 German National Cohort (NAKO) participants aged 19-75 years. In 1,012 Cooperative Health Research in the Region of Augsburg (KORA)-Age participants aged 65-93 years, we calculated the age-standardised prevalence of low grip strength and time-dependent sensitivity and specificity for all-cause mortality. RESULTS: Grip strength increased in the third and fourth decade of life and declined afterwards. Calculated cut-off points for low grip strength were 29 kg for men and 18 kg for women. In KORA-Age, the age-standardised prevalence of low grip strength was 1.5× higher for NAKO-derived (17.7%) compared to EWGSOP2 (11.7%) cut-off points. NAKO-derived cut-off points yielded a higher sensitivity and lower specificity for all-cause mortality. CONCLUSIONS: Cut-off points for low grip strength from German population-based data were 2 kg higher than the EWGSOP2 cut-off points. Higher cut-off points increase the sensitivity, thereby suggesting an intervention for more patients at risk, while other individuals might receive additional diagnostics/treatment without the urgent need. Research on the effectiveness of intervention in patients with low grip strength defined by different cut-off points is needed.
引用
- Huemer MT, Kluttig A, Fischer B, et al. Grip strength values and cut-off points based on over 200,000 adults of the German National Cohort - a comparison to the EWGSOP2 cut-off points. Age Ageing. 2023. PMID: 36702514. doi:10.1093/ageing/afac324
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。