Stepping On 项目参与者与匹配对照的跌倒相关医疗服务使用:45 and Up 研究中的非随机观察性试验
该研究利用 45 and Up 研究数据,比较 1,452 名 Stepping On 参与者与 5,799 名匹配对照的跌倒相关医疗服务使用率。结果显示参与者使用率随时间上升且高于对照(RR 1.47-1.82),项目前 6 个月出现峰值;分层分析显示参与者项目后较项目前使用减少(RR 0.32-0.48),而对照无变化(RR 1.00-1.25)。Stepping On 似可缓解参与者跌倒相关医疗服务使用的上升趋势,但非随机设计需谨慎解读。
要点
- Stepping On 参与者跌倒相关医疗服务使用率高于匹配对照(RR 1.47-1.82)。
- 参与者项目后较项目前跌倒相关服务使用减少(RR 0.32-0.48),对照无变化。
- 性别为医疗服务使用的显著效应修饰因素(交互 P < 0.05)。
核心结论
- Stepping On 似可缓解参与者跌倒相关医疗服务使用的上升趋势。
- 鉴于非随机设计,结果需谨慎解读。
研究设计与样本
- 非随机观察性试验,使用 45 and Up 研究数据。
- Stepping On 参与者与未参与者按 1:4 比例提取,最终分析 1,452 名参与者与 5,799 名对照。
- 采用多水平泊松回归模型比较链接常规收集数据中的跌倒相关医疗服务使用率,并调整有向无环图确定的最小充分混杂因素集。
主要发现
- 医疗服务使用随时间增加,且 Stepping On 参与者使用更高(RR 1.47-1.82),项目参与前 6 个月出现使用峰值。
- 显著交互作用表明参与者与对照的医疗服务使用模式不同:分层分析显示参与者项目后较项目前跌倒相关医疗服务使用减少(RR 0.32-0.48),而对照无变化(RR 1.00-1.25)。
- 性别为医疗服务使用的显著效应修饰因素(交互 P < 0.05)。
临床怎么用
- 在老年医学科评估中,可考虑将 Stepping On 等跌倒预防项目用于有跌倒风险的长者,以可能缓解跌倒相关医疗服务使用的上升。
- 解读本项目效果时需结合其非随机设计,注意残余混杂可能。
局限性
- 研究为非随机设计,结果需谨慎解读。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Falls and fall-related health service use among older adults continue to increase. The New South Wales Health Department, Australia, is delivering the Stepping On fall prevention programme at scale. We compared fall-related health service use in Stepping On participants and matched controls. METHODS: A non-randomised observational trial was undertaken using 45 and Up Study data. 45 and Up Study participants who did and did not participate in Stepping On were extracted in a 1:4 ratio. Rates of fall-related health service use from linked routinely collected data were compared between participants and controls over time using multilevel Poisson regression models with adjustment for the minimally sufficient set of confounders identified from a directed acyclic graph. RESULTS: Data from 1,452 Stepping On participants and 5,799 controls were analysed. Health service use increased over time and was greater in Stepping On participants (rate ratios (RRs) 1.47-1.82) with a spike in use in the 6 months prior to programme participation. Significant interactions indicated differential patterns of health service use in participants and controls: stratified analyses revealed less fall-related health service use in participants post-programme compared to pre-programme (RRs 0.32-0.48), but no change in controls' health service use (RRs 1.00-1.25). Gender was identified to be a significant effect modifier for health service use (P < 0.05 for interaction). DISCUSSION: Stepping On appeared to mitigate participants' rising fall-related health service use. Best practice methods were used to maximise this study's validity, but cautious interpretation of results is required given its non-randomised nature.
引用
- Paul SS, Khalatbari-Soltani S, Dolja-Gore X, et al. Fall-related health service use in Stepping On programme participants and matched controls: a non-randomised observational trial within the 45 and Up Study. Age Ageing. 2022. PMID: 36580389. doi:10.1093/ageing/afac272
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。