将沟通质量问卷应用于初级保健中认知障碍患者及其家属的预试验
本研究在80岁及以上认知障碍初级保健患者及其家庭照护者的双人组中,对沟通质量问卷(QOC)进行预试验和效度试验。预试验(13对)使用原版量表时,患者与家属对临终(EOL)沟通评分分歧明显,且「不知道」回答比例较高;效度试验(43对)采用跳转逻辑改良后,「不知道」回答极少(<1%),患者与家属EOL评分相近。
要点
- 原版QOC的EOL子量表在初级保健中评估很少发生的对话,患者和家属易困惑。
- 预试验中家属「不知道」回答占32%,患者占5%;改良后效度试验中均<1%。
- 改良后EOL沟通行为多报告为未发生(患者76%、家属73%)。
核心结论
- 原版QOC的EOL子量表涉及初级保健中很少发生的对话,但对认知障碍老年人很重要。
- 子量表改良可能减少困惑和回答不确定性,提高测量准确性。
研究设计与样本
- 报告已完成预试验和正在进行的预先照护计划效度试验的基线数据。
- 对象为80岁及以上认知障碍初级保健患者及其家庭照护者组成的双人组。
- 预试验纳入13对双人组,效度试验纳入43对双人组(NCT04593472)。
主要发现
- 预试验中患者和家属一般沟通评分相似(9.65和9.60),但EOL评分分歧(4.23和5.88)。
- 预试验中「不知道」回答占患者5%、家属32%。
- 效度试验中EOL沟通行为多报告为未发生(患者76%、家属73%)。
- 效度试验中患者和家属EOL子量表评分相似(2.23和2.26),「不知道」回答<1%。
关键数值与推荐
- QOC两个子量表评分范围0(最差)到10(最好)。
- 改良版先询问EOL沟通是否发生(是/否),回答是者再评分。
临床怎么用
- 在认知障碍老年患者中应用QOC时,可考虑跳转逻辑以减少困惑和回答不确定性。
- 评估EOL沟通时需注意初级保健中此类对话可能很少发生。
局限性
- 预试验样本量小(13对双人组),效度试验为基线数据。
- 原文未报告效度试验的完整结果和长期随访数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The quality of communication (QOC) questionnaire has been widely used to assess foundational aspects of patient-clinician communication about end-of-life (EOL) care. However, this instrument has never before been fielded with primary care patients who have cognitive impairment and their caregivers, a population with unique communication needs. DESIGN: We report on baseline data from a completed pilot study and ongoing efficacy trial of advance care planning involving dyads of primary care patients ages 80 and older with cognitive impairment and their family care partners. Two QOC subscales assessed ratings of general communication and EOL care communication from 0 ("worst") to 10 ("best"). Due to challenges piloting the EOL subscale, we integrated skip logic to improve cognitive accessibility and measurement precision. Participants were first asked whether EOL communication occurred (yes/no); those responding affirmatively were subsequently asked to rate communication. We report experiences with EOL subscale adaptations from our ongoing trial (NCT04593472). RESULTS: Using the original instrument in our pilot (13 dyads), mean patient and family general communication ratings were similar (9.65 and 9.60, respectively), but EOL ratings diverged (4.23 and 5.88, respectively), and "Don't Know" comprised 5% of patient and 32% of family responses. Interviewers reported patient and family participants expressed confusion when asked to rate EOL communication behaviors that had not occurred. Using the adapted instrument in our efficacy trial (43 dyads), EOL communication behaviors were most often reported as not having occurred (76% of patient and 73% of family responses across all items). Mean patient and family EOL subscale ratings were similar (2.23 and 2.26) and responses of "Don't Know" were minimal (<1%). CONCLUSION: The original QOC EOL subscale involves rating conversations that rarely occur in primary care but are important for older adults with cognitive impairment. Subscale adaptations may reduce confusion and response uncertainty and improve measurement accuracy.
引用
- Reiff JS, Cagle J, Zhang T, et al. Fielding the quality of communication questionnaire to persons with cognitive impairment and their family in primary care: A pilot study. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2022. PMID: 36069000. doi:10.1111/jgs.18034
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。