文献速递老年慢病共病管理老年综合评估

晚期多重共病老年人的不确定性体验:系统综述与主题综合

Total uncertainty: a systematic review and thematic synthesis of experiences of uncertainty in older people with advanced multimorbidity, their informal carers and health professionals.
PubMed 文献 · Age Ageing · 2022-01-01

该系统综述纳入44篇文章(40项研究),涉及晚期多重共病老年人、非正式照护者及卫生专业人员的不确定性体验。主题综合提出「完全不确定性」概念,涵盖五个领域,参与者以主动或被动方式应对不确定性。

要点

  • 「完全不确定性」涵盖疾病评估管理、碎片化照护沟通、不堪重负、他人不确定性和持续变化五领域。
  • 患者、照护者与专业人员在不稳定性体验上共享相似领域,提示共同理解可行。
  • 该五领域框架可作为照护晚期多重共病老年人的组织工具。

核心结论

  • 「完全不确定性」新概念代表对晚期多重共病疾病体验理解的进步。
  • 患者、照护者和卫生专业人员在不稳定性领域体验相似,共享理解可行。
  • 完全不确定性的各领域构成照护多重共病老年人的有用组织框架。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述与主题综合,检索9个数据库的已发表和灰色定性文献(Prospero CRD 42021227480)。
  • 纳入标准为晚期多重共病老年人及向其提供照护的非正式照护者/专业人员;排除早期多重共病或对不确定性关注不足者。
  • 采用证据权重评估纳入文章质量,对多视角体验及对不确定性的反应进行主题综合。

主要发现

  • 从4738条唯一检索结果中纳入44篇文章,涉及40项研究。
  • 22篇关注患者不确定性体验(n=460),15篇关注照护者体验(n=197),19篇关注卫生专业人员体验(n=490),10篇探讨多视角。
  • 识别出跨五个领域的「完全不确定性」共享体验:评估和管理多种疾病;碎片化照护和沟通;感到不堪重负;他人的不确定性;持续变化。
  • 参与者通过主动(应对、回避)或被动(接受)方式回应不确定性。

临床怎么用

  • 「完全不确定性」五领域框架可作为卫生专业人员照护晚期多重共病老年人的组织工具。
  • 认识患者、照护者与专业人员在不稳定性体验上的共享领域,有助于促进共同理解。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: uncertainty pervades the complex illness trajectories experienced by older adults with multimorbidity. Uncertainty is experienced by older people, their informal carers and professionals providing care, yet is incompletely understood. We aimed to identify and synthesise systematically the experience of uncertainty in advanced multimorbidity from patient, carer and professional perspectives. DESIGN: systematic literature review of published and grey qualitative literature from 9 databases (Prospero CRD 42021227480). PARTICIPANTS: older people with advanced multimorbidity, and informal carers/professionals providing care to this group. Exclusion criteria: early multimorbidity, insufficient focus on uncertainty. ANALYSIS: weight-of-evidence assessment was used to appraise included articles. We undertook thematic synthesis of multi-perspective experiences and response to uncertainty. RESULTS: from 4,738 unique search results, we included 44 articles relating to 40 studies. 22 focused on patient experiences of uncertainty (n = 460), 15 on carer experiences (n = 197), and 19 on health professional experiences (n = 490), with 10 exploring multiple perspectives. We identified a shared experience of 'Total Uncertainty' across five domains: 'appraising and managing multiple illnesses'; 'fragmented care and communication'; 'feeling overwhelmed'; 'uncertainty of others' and 'continual change'. Participants responded to uncertainty by either active (addressing, avoiding) or passive (accepting) means. CONCLUSIONS: the novel concept of 'Total Uncertainty' represents a step change in our understanding of illness experience in advanced multimorbidity. Patients, carers and health professionals experienced uncertainty in similar domains, suggesting a shared understanding is feasible. The domains of total uncertainty form a useful organising framework for health professionals caring for older adults with multimorbidity.

来源:Age Ageing,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Etkind SN, Li J, Louca J, et al. Total uncertainty: a systematic review and thematic synthesis of experiences of uncertainty in older people with advanced multimorbidity, their informal carers and health professionals. Age Ageing. 2022. PMID: 35977149. doi:10.1093/ageing/afac188

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。