居家自测体位性血压的可行性、可靠性与安全性
在英格兰东北部跌倒与晕厥门诊开展的服务改进项目,纳入25例≥60岁、中位临床衰弱评分5分的患者,比较患者按书面指导自测与临床医生测得的体位性血压及体位性低血压诊断的一致性。患者自测与医生诊断体位性低血压的 agreement 为95%(Cohen's kappa 0.90(0.70, 1.00)),20例无需临床协助完成有效评估,提示居家自测可靠、安全且可接受。
要点
- 患者自测与医生诊断体位性低血压的一致性达95%(kappa 0.90)。
- 收缩压下降相关性 r=0.80,自测值平均高估1(-6, 3)mmHg。
- Bland-Altman 界限为+17与-20 mmHg,超出预设临床重要差异±5 mmHg。
核心结论
- 居家患者自测体位性血压是诊断体位性低血压可靠、安全且可接受的方法。
研究设计与样本
- 英格兰东北部跌倒与晕厥门诊的服务改进项目。
- 纳入标准为年龄≥60岁、有体位性血压测量指征且身体与认知上能完成测量。
- 排除养老院居民及亲自到门诊就诊者。
- 患者按书面指导独立完成自测,随后由临床医生在10分钟仰卧休息后测量。
主要发现
- 患者与医生诊断体位性低血压的一致性为95%(Cohen's kappa 0.90(0.70, 1.00))。
- 体位性收缩压下降相关性 r=0.80,患者自测值平均高估1(-6, 3)mmHg。
- Bland-Altman 分析的一致性界限为+17与-20 mmHg,大于预设最大临床重要差异±5 mmHg。
- 20例参与者在无临床协助下完成有效的体位性血压评估。
关键数值与推荐
- 诊断体位性低血压的患者自测与医生测量一致性为95%,Cohen's kappa 0.90(0.70, 1.00)。
- 收缩压下降相关性 r=0.80,自测值平均高估1(-6, 3)mmHg。
- 一致性界限+17与-20 mmHg,超过预设最大临床重要差异±5 mmHg。
临床怎么用
- 对≥60岁、有体位性血压测量指征且能按书面指导操作的患者,可考虑居家自测体位性血压以辅助诊断体位性低血压。
- 自测收缩压下降与医生测量强相关,但个体层面一致性界限较宽,判读时应结合临床。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性相关内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A postural blood pressure assessment is required to diagnose Orthostatic Hypotension. With increasing remote consultations, alternative methods of performing postural blood pressure assessment are required. OBJECTIVE: Determine whether postural blood pressure measurement at home, without a clinician, is reliable, feasible and safe. DESIGN: Service improvement project within a falls and syncope service in Northeast England. SUBJECTS: Eligibility criteria: aged ≥60 years; postural blood pressure measurement is indicated and is physically and cognitively able to perform. Exclusion criteria: nursing home residents, attending clinic in person. METHODS: Postural blood pressure measurements were performed in patients' homes under clinical observation. Patient-led assessments were performed independent of the clinician, following written guidance. This was followed by a clinical-led assessment after 10-minute supine rest. OUTCOMES: Agreement between patient and clinician derived postural blood pressure values and diagnosis of Orthostatic Hypotension; intervention safety, feasibility and acceptability. RESULTS: Twenty-eight patients were eligible and 25 participated (mean age 75, median Clinical Frailty Score five).There was 95% agreement (Cohen's kappa 0.90 (0.70, 1.00)) between patient and clinician derived readings to diagnose orthostatic hypotension.Postural systolic blood pressure drop correlated strongly (r = 0.80), with patient derived readings overestimating by 1 (-6, 3) mmHg. Limits of agreement, determined via Bland Altman analysis, were +17 and -20 mmHg, greater than pre-determined maximum clinically important difference (±5 mmHg).Twenty participants performed valid postural blood pressure assessments without clinical assistance. CONCLUSIONS: Patient-led postural blood pressure assessment at home is a reliable, safe and acceptable method for diagnosing Orthostatic Hypotension.
引用
- Gibbon JR, Parry SW, Witham MD, et al. Feasibility, reliability and safety of self-assessed orthostatic blood pressure at home. Age Ageing. 2022. PMID: 35776671. doi:10.1093/ageing/afac153
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。