脐疝开放与腹腔镜腹腔内补片修补的相对获益是否取决于缺损直径?
基于注册研究比较776例开放与1019例腹腔镜腹腔内补片修补脐疝的早期及2年结局。腹腔镜组在小型和 medium 疝的手术部位并发症、大型疝的复发率及累计再手术率上更优,但术后早期疼痛及小型疝的慢性疼痛更高。开放修补在小型疝中仍有应用价值。
要点
- 腹腔镜修补在小型和 medium 疝的手术部位并发症、大型疝复发率及累计再手术率上优于开放。
- 腹腔镜组术后第1天及1个月的早期疼痛在所有疝尺寸中均更高。
- 小型疝中腹腔镜组2年中重度慢性疼痛发生率更高,开放修补仍有优势。
核心结论
- 开放与腹腔镜腹腔内补片修补的获益与缺陷比与欧洲疝学会缺损直径相关。
- 在中大型疝中,腹腔镜修补的获益超过其缺陷。
- 在小型疝中,低复发率、较少的早期和慢性疼痛及更好的日间手术率提示开放修补仍有地位。
研究设计与样本
- 基于注册的研究,比较2011至2019年776例开放与1019例连续腹腔镜腹腔内补片修补的早期及2年结局。
主要发现
- 再手术肠梗阻发生率为0.3%。
- 小型疝(<2 cm)手术部位并发症:腹腔镜组0.3% vs 开放组2.4%(P = .041)。
- medium 疝(2-4 cm)手术部位并发症:腹腔镜组1.4% vs 开放组5.9%(P = .0002)。
- 大型疝(≥4 cm)复发率:腹腔镜组0.0% vs 开放组8.6%(P = .0195)。
- 累计再手术率:腹腔镜组0.9% vs 开放组2.2%(P = .021)。
关键数值与推荐
- 术后第1天及1个月早期疼痛率腹腔镜组在所有疝尺寸中更高(P < .001)。
- 小型疝2年中重度慢性疼痛率腹腔镜组8.1% vs 开放组2.4%(P = .049)。
临床怎么用
- 中大型脐疝可优先考虑腹腔镜腹腔内补片修补以降低复发和再手术。
- 小型脐疝需权衡腹腔镜的慢性疼痛风险,开放修补仍可选用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to assess whether the respective values of open and laparoscopic intraperitoneal repairs of umbilical hernias are related to the European Hernia Society diameter of defects. METHODS: This registry-based study compared the early and 2-year outcomes of 776 open versus 1,019 consecutive laparoscopic intraperitoneal repairs performed from 2011 to 2019. RESULTS: Intraperitoneal mesh repair, either laparoscopic or open, was found to be a safe procedure at the 2-year follow-up. The incidence of reoperated bowel obstructions was 0.3%. Compared with the open group: (1) postoperative surgical site occurrences in small (<2 cm) or medium (2-4 cm) hernias (0.3% vs 2.4%; P = .041; 1.4% vs 5.9%; P = .0002); (2) recurrence rates in large (≥4 cm) umbilical hernias (0.0% vs 8.6%; P = .0195); and (3) cumulative reoperation rates (0.9% vs 2.2%; P = .021) were significantly better in the laparoscopic group. Conversely, the rate of early pain on day 1 and 1 month postsurgery was higher in the laparoscopic group, for all hernia sizes (P < .001). The rate of moderate or severe chronic pain at 2 years was significantly higher in the laparoscopic group (8.1% vs 2.4%; P = .049) for small hernias. CONCLUSION: The respective benefit to drawback ratios for open versus laparoscopic intraperitoneal repairs were related to the European Hernia Society diameter of hernia defect. In medium-large hernias, the benefits of laparoscopic repair overrode its drawbacks. In small hernias, the low recurrence rate, reduced early and chronic pain, and better rate of ambulatory surgery suggest there is still a place for open repair.
引用
- Frey S, Jurczak F, Fromont G, et al. Are the relative benefits of open versus laparoscopic intraperitoneal mesh repair of umbilical hernias dependent on the diameter of the defect? Surgery. 2021. PMID: 34503852. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2021.08.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。