腹部手术机器人辅助技术的成本、财务影响与常规使用指导
本研究分析34984例腹部手术患者,比较开放、腹腔镜与机器人辅助(RA)技术的成本和临床结局。结果显示三种技术临床结局相似,但RA技术成本显著更高,平均净边际为-1%,仅商业支付方下为正。价值分析不支持在腹股沟疝修补和胆囊切除术中常规使用RA技术。
要点
- RA技术临床结局与开放和腹腔镜相似,但成本显著更高。
- 腹股沟疝修补和胆囊切除术的价值分析不支持常规使用RA。
- 子宫切除和结肠切除RA成本更高,需有临床理由且由成本高效提供者使用。
核心结论
- RA技术未产生显著临床优势且成本远高于相似手术技术。
- 价值分析不支持腹股沟疝修补和胆囊切除术常规使用RA技术。
- 子宫切除和结肠切除的RA技术成本更高,应仅在适当临床理由下由成本高效提供者常规使用。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析34984例择期手术患者,包括胆囊切除、结肠切除、腹股沟疝修补、子宫切除和阑尾切除。
- 按年龄、BMI、风险等级、手术时间、住院时间和再入院率分析。
- 计算每种手术技术的平均直接成本、总成本每例和净边际每例。
主要发现
- 所有技术临床结局相似。
- 腹股沟疝修补9412例:开放48%平均直接成本2138美元,腹腔镜29%为3468美元,RA 23%为6880美元。
- 胆囊切除8316例:腹腔镜94%平均直接成本2846美元,RA 4.4%为7139美元,开放16%为3931美元。
- 结肠切除3432例:开放42%平均直接成本12849美元,腹腔镜38%为10714美元,RA 20%为15133美元。
- 子宫切除12614例:RA 42%门诊平均直接成本8213美元,腹腔镜39%为5181美元,开放19%为4894美元。
关键数值与推荐
- RA手术平均全局净边际为-1%,仅商业支付方下为正。
- 腹股沟疝修补和胆囊切除术的价值分析不支持常规使用RA技术。
- 子宫切除和结肠切除的RA技术成本远高于开放和腹腔镜,应仅在适当临床理由下由成本高效提供者常规使用。
临床怎么用
- 腹股沟疝修补和胆囊切除术不推荐常规使用RA技术。
- 子宫切除和结肠切除使用RA需有适当临床理由并考虑成本效率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: This study was designed to define the value, cost, and fiscal impact of robotic-assisted procedures in abdominal surgery and provide clinical guidance for its routine use. METHODS: 34,984 patients who underwent an elective cholecystectomy, colectomy, inguinal hernia repair, hysterectomy, or appendectomy over a 24-month period were analyzed by age, BMI, risk class, operating time, LOS and readmission rate. Average Direct and Total Cost per Case (ADC, TCC) and Net Margin per Case (NM) were produced for each surgical technique, i.e., open, laparoscopic, and robotic assisted (RA). RESULTS: All techniques were shown to have similar clinical outcomes. 9412 inguinal herniorrhaphy were performed (48% open with $2138 ADC, 29% laparoscopy with $3468 ADC, 23% RA with $6880 ADC); 8316 cholecystectomies (94% laparoscopy with $2846 ADC, 4.4% RA with a $7139 ADC, 16% open with a $3931 ADC); 3432 colectomies (42% open with a $12,849 ADC, 38% laparoscopy with a $10,714, 20% RA with a $15,133); 12,614 hysterectomies [42% RA with a $8213 Outpatient (OP) ADC, 39% laparoscopy $5181 OP ADC, 19% open $4894 OP ADC]. Average Global NM is - 1% for RA procedures and only positive with commercial payors. CONCLUSION: RA techniques do not produce significant clinical enhancements than similar surgical techniques with identical outcomes while their costs are much higher. The produced value analysis does not support the routine use of RA techniques for inguinal hernia repair and cholecystectomy. RA techniques for hysterectomies and colectomies are also performed at much higher cost than open and laparoscopic techniques, should only be routinely used with appropriate clinical justification and by cost efficient surgical providers.
引用
- Quilici PJ, Wolberg H, McConnell N, et al. Operating costs, fiscal impact, value analysis and guidance for the routine use of robotic technology in abdominal surgical procedures. Surg Endosc. 2021. PMID: 33835252. doi:10.1007/s00464-021-08428-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。