文献速递围术期管理与 ERAS疝与腹壁外科

全局与任务特异性术后反馈在手术操作学习中的比较

Global versus task-specific postoperative feedback in surgical procedure learning.
PubMed 文献 · Surgery · 2021-02-13

结果显示两组性能评分改善无显著差异(P=.100),但OCHRA组在时间(371.0±223.4 vs 274.6±341.6;P=.027)和路径长度(53.5±42.4 vs 34.7±39.0;P=.046)的改善显著更优。分层分析显示,低视觉空间能力者中OCHRA组的改善更明显(时间P=.032,路径长度P=.053)。

要点

  • 任务特异性OCHRA反馈在改善新手手术操作时间和路径长度上优于全局OSATS反馈。
  • 两组在整体性能评分改善上无显著差异(P=.100)。
  • OCHRA反馈的优势主要体现在低视觉空间能力的个体中。

核心结论

  • 对于新手,任务特异性(OCHRA)反馈在改善手术技能的时间与路径长度方面比全局评分量表(OSATS)更有效。
  • 任务特异性反馈的效果主要存在于视觉空间能力较低的个体中。

研究设计与样本

  • 随机对照试验,医学生被分配至OCHRA反馈组(n=25)或OSATS反馈组(n=25)。
  • 视觉空间能力通过心理旋转测试测量。
  • 参与者在模拟模型上执行两次开放腹股沟疝修补术,第一次术后提供反馈。
  • 采用全局评分量表(性能评分)和手部运动分析(时间与路径长度)盲法评估表现改善。

主要发现

  • 性能评分的平均改善在OCHRA与OSATS反馈组间无显著差异(P=.100)。
  • 时间的平均改善在OCHRA组显著大于OSATS组(371.0±223.4 vs 274.6±341.6;P=.027)。
  • 路径长度的平均改善在OCHRA组显著大于OSATS组(53.5±42.4 vs 34.7±39.0;P=.046)。
  • 按心理旋转测试得分分层,仅在低视觉空间能力个体中观察到时间(P=.032)和路径长度(P=.053)的更大改善。

临床怎么用

  • 在手术操作教学中,可优先采用任务特异性反馈工具(如OCHRA)以优化新手的手术时间和路径长度。
  • 对于视觉空间能力较低的学习者,任务特异性反馈可能带来更明显的技能改善。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Task-specific checklists and global rating scales are both recommended assessment tools to provide constructive feedback on surgical performance. This study evaluated the most effective feedback tool by comparing the effects of the Observational Clinical Human Reliability Analysis (OCHRA) and the Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skills (OSATS) on surgical performance in relation to the visual-spatial ability of the learners. METHODS: In a randomized controlled trial, medical students were allocated to either the OCHRA (n = 25) or OSATS (n = 25) feedback group. Visual-spatial ability was measured by a Mental Rotation Test. Participants performed an open inguinal hernia repair procedure on a simulation model twice. Feedback was provided after the first procedure. Improvement in performance was evaluated blindly using a global rating scale (performance score) and hand-motion analysis (time and path length). RESULTS: Mean improvement in performance score was not significantly different between the OCHRA and OSATS feedback groups (P = .100). However, mean improvement in time (371.0 ± 223.4 vs 274.6 ± 341.6; P = .027) and path length (53.5 ± 42.4 vs 34.7 ± 39.0; P = .046) was significantly greater in the OCHRA feedback group. When stratified by mental rotation test scores, the greater improvement in time (P = .032) and path length (P = .053) was observed only among individuals with low visual-spatial abilities. CONCLUSION: A task-specific (OCHRA) feedback is more effective in improving surgical skills in terms of time and path length in novices compared to a global rating scale (OSATS). The effects of a task-specific feedback are present mostly in individuals with lower visual-spatial abilities.

来源:Surgery,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Nazari T, Bogomolova K, Ridderbos M, et al. Global versus task-specific postoperative feedback in surgical procedure learning. Surgery. 2021. PMID: 33589246. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2020.12.038

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。