微创远端胰腺切除术:机器人辅助与直接手动腹腔镜的病例匹配成本分析
结果显示RDP组转换率显著低于LDP组(2.9%和0% vs 14.3%,p=0.045),但总成本显著更高(p<0.001);仅考虑可变成本时,Xi-RDP组与LDP组差异不再显著(p=0.099),且计划保脾时RDP与LDP的可变成本差异亦无统计学意义。结论认为机器人手术因购置和维护成本更高而更昂贵,但在高通量多学科中心可能通过优化成本使差异缩小,保脾时可能尤其适合机器人手术。
要点
- RDP组转换率显著低于LDP组(2.9%和0% vs 14.3%,p=0.045)。
- LDP组总成本显著低于RDP组(p<0.001)。
- 仅可变成本时Xi-RDP与LDP差异不显著(p=0.099)。
核心结论
- 机器人远端胰腺切除术因购置和维护成本更高而比腹腔镜更昂贵。
- 仅考虑可变成本时差异缩小,提示在高通量多学科中心可能优化成本。
- 计划保脾时机器人手术可能尤其适用。
研究设计与样本
- 匹配后形成三组各35例:Si-RDP组、Xi-RDP组、LDP组。
- 使用广义线性回归模型调整协变量比较总成本(含可变成本和固定成本)。
主要发现
- 转换率:Si-RDP组2.9%、Xi-RDP组0%、LDP组14.3%(p=0.045)。
- 平均手术时间:Xi-RDP组226分钟,Si-RDP组262分钟,LDP组247分钟(无统计学显著性)。
- 术后并发症率和住院时间三组间无显著差异。
- LDP组转换病例的住院时间显著更长:15.6天 vs 9.8天(p=0.039)。
- LDP组总成本显著低于RDP组(p<0.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- 多因素分析:LDP组与Xi-RDP组可变成本差异p=0.099,无统计学显著性。
- 计划保脾时,LDP组与Si-RDP组可变成本差异p=0.115,与Xi-RDP组p=0.261,均无统计学显著性。
临床怎么用
- 机器人远端胰腺切除术成本更高,需权衡转换率降低等潜在获益。
- 在高通量多学科中心,仅可变成本差异可能缩小,可关注成本优化。
- 计划保脾的微创远端胰腺切除术可考虑机器人手术。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计。
- 样本量有限(匹配后每组35例)。
- 单中心数据,成本结构可能受中心特征影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Few studies have reported a structured cost analysis of robotic distal pancreatectomy (RDP), and none have compared the relative costs between the robotic-assisted surgery (RAS) and the direct manual laparoscopy (DML) in this setting. The aim of the present study is to address this issue by comparing surgical outcomes and costs of RDP and laparoscopic distal pancreatectomies (LDP). METHODS: Eighty-eight RDP and 47 LDP performed between January 2008 and January 2020 were retrospectively analyzed. Three comparable groups of 35 patients each (Si-RDP-group, Xi-RDP group, LDP-group) were obtained matching 1:1 the RDP-groups with the LDP-group. Overall costs, including overall variable costs (OVC) and fixed costs were compared using generalized linear regression model adjusting for covariates. RESULTS: The conversion rate was significantly lower in the Si-RDP-group and Xi-RDP-group: 2.9% and 0%, respectively, versus 14.3% in the LDP-group (p = 0.045). Although not statistically significant, the mean operative time was lower in Xi-RDP-group: 226 min versus 262 min for Si-RDP-group and 247 min for LDP-group. The overall post-operative complications rate and the length of hospital stay (LOS) were not significantly different between the three groups. In LDP-group, the LOS of converted cases was significantly longer: 15.6 versus 9.8 days (p = 0.039). Overall costs of LDP-group were significantly lower than RDP-groups, (p < 0.001). At multivariate analysis OVC resulted no longer statistically significantly different between LDP-group and Xi-RDP-group (p = 0.099), and between LDP-group and the RDP-groups when the spleen preservation was indicated (p = 0.115 and p = 0.261 for Si-RDP-group and Xi-RDP-group, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: RAS is more expensive than DML for DP because of higher acquisition and maintenance costs. The flattening of these differences considering only the variable costs, in a high-volume multidisciplinary center for RAS, suggests a possible optimization of the costs in this setting. RAS might be particularly indicated for minimally invasive DP when the spleen preservation is scheduled.
引用
- Di Franco G, Peri A, Lorenzoni V, et al. Minimally invasive distal pancreatectomy: a case-matched cost-analysis between robot-assisted surgery and direct manual laparoscopy. Surg Endosc. 2021. PMID: 33534074. doi:10.1007/s00464-021-08332-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。