SAGES成员对SAGES指南质量与价值的评价
548名回应者中多数经常或偶尔使用SAGES指南,认为其有价值、质量高于平均水平且易于使用。成员建议更及时更新和改善网络获取,主题建议集中在疝、减重、机器人、肝胆胰和结直肠外科。
要点
- SAGES指南被成员频繁或偶尔使用,83%认为有价值,86%认为质量高于平均水平。
- 成员强烈支持SAGES继续遵循严格的指南制定流程。
- 常见建议包括更及时更新指南和改善网络访问。
核心结论
- SAGES指南被用户频繁使用,并因其质量和内容受到重视。
- 成员提出的主题和建议可指导新指南的制定和现有指南及流程的完善。
研究设计与样本
- 调查包含18个关于SAGES指南和综述使用与评价的问题,并征集新指南主题和改进建议。
- 共548名成员回应;大多数为微创外科(41%)或普通外科(33%),学术机构(46%)与非学术机构(24%私人执业,23%医院受雇)分布均衡。
主要发现
- 22%的回应者频繁使用SAGES指南,68%偶尔使用。
- 83%认为指南有价值,86%认为质量高于平均水平,74%认为易于使用。
- 35%认为SAGES继续遵循严格指南制定流程重要,58%认为非常重要。
- 442条重叠主题建议中,60%集中在疝、减重、机器人、肝胆胰和结直肠外科。
临床怎么用
- 外科医生可继续将SAGES指南作为临床决策的参考工具,其质量和易用性得到成员认可。
- 指南制定方应关注成员对及时更新和网络访问改善的需求。
- 新指南主题可优先考虑疝、减重、机器人、肝胆胰和结直肠外科。
局限性
- 调查为匿名在线问卷,回应者仅548名SAGES成员,可能存在选择偏倚。
- 调查于2019年进行,结果可能不代表当前观点。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic Surgeons (SAGES) Guidelines Committee develops evidence-based guidelines for practicing surgeons using standard methodology. Our objective was to survey the SAGES membership regarding guidelines' quality, use, and value and identify topics of interest for new guideline development. METHODS: An anonymous online survey was emailed in October 2019 to SAGES members. Respondents were asked 18 questions on their use and evaluation of SAGES guidelines and SAGES reviews and to provide suggestions for new guideline topics and areas of improvement. The survey was open for 6 weeks with a 3-week reminder. RESULTS: Of 548 responders, most were minimally invasive (41%) or general surgeons (33%). There was an even distribution between academic (46%) and non-academic practice (24% private practice, 23% hospital employed). Most used SAGES guidelines frequently (22%) or occasionally (68%) and found them to be of value (83%), above average quality (86%), and easy to use (74%). While most stated it was important (35%) or very important (58%) that SAGES continues to follow "rigorous guidelines development processes," common suggestions were for more timely updates and improved web access. Of 442 overlapping topic suggestions, 60% fell into overarching categories of hernia, bariatric, robotic, HPB, and colorectal surgery. CONCLUSIONS: The SAGES guidelines are used frequently and valued by its users for their quality and content. Topics proposed by SAGES members and valuable insight from this survey can guide creation of new guidelines and refinement of established guidelines and processes.
引用
- Dirks RC, Walsh D, Haggerty S, et al. SAGES guidelines: an appraisal of their quality and value by SAGES members. Surg Endosc. 2021. PMID: 33528662. doi:10.1007/s00464-021-08323-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。