腹壁疝修补与腹壁重建补片研究中利益冲突报告准确性分析
该研究比较了2014至2018年间12种普外科与整形外科期刊中至少含1名美国作者的补片相关研究,将其声明的利益冲突与Open Payments数据库付款记录比对。结果显示81.0%的研究存在未准确声明利益冲突的作者,44.8%的作者未准确声明,末位作者未声明付款风险最高。
要点
- 多数补片相关腹壁疝研究未准确声明利益冲突。
- 末位作者未声明付款风险最高(OR 3.59,95%CI 2.02-6.20)。
- 当前利益冲突披露政策似不足以确保发表透明性。
核心结论
- 多数腹壁疝修补与腹壁重建补片研究未准确声明利益冲突。
- 末位作者未披露付款的风险最高。
- 现行利益冲突披露政策似乎不足以确保出版物透明性。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入2014至2018年间12种主要同行评审普外科与整形外科期刊中至少含1名美国作者的研究。
- 将声明的利益冲突与CMS维护的Open Payments数据库在接收当年及前一年的付款记录进行比对。
- 若研究或作者从8家主要补片公司中任一家获得超过100.00美元付款即视为存在利益冲突。
主要发现
- 多变量分析显示末位作者未声明付款风险最高(OR 3.59,95%CI 2.02-6.20)。
- 中间作者未声明付款风险显著高于第一作者(OR 1.64,95%CI 1.04-2.56)。
临床怎么用
- 阅读补片相关腹壁疝研究时应警惕未声明的产业利益冲突,尤其关注末位作者。
- 临床决策参考此类研究时需结合利益冲突透明度综合评估证据可靠性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To examine the accuracy of the reporting of conflicts of interest (COI) among studies related to mesh use in ventral hernia repair and abdominal wall reconstruction. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Accurate declaration of COI is integral to ensuring transparency of study results. Multiple studies have demonstrated undeclared COI are prevalent in surgical literature. METHODS: Studies with at least 1 American author accepted between 2014 and 2018 in 12 major, peer-reviewed general surgery and plastic surgery journals were included. Declared COI were compared with payments listed in the "Open Payments" database [maintained by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS)] during the year of acceptance and 1 year prior. Studies and authors were considered to have a COI if they received payments from any of 8 major mesh companies totaling >$100.00 from each company. Risk factors for undeclared COI were determined at the study and author levels. RESULTS: One hundred twenty-six studies (553 authors) were included. One hundred two studies (81.0%) had one or more authors who received payments from industry and inaccurately declared their COI. Two hundred forty-eight authors (44.8%) did not declare their COI accurately. On multivariate analysis, last authors were found to be at highest risk for undeclared payments (OR 3.59, 95%CI 2.02-6.20), whereas middle authors were at significantly higher risk for undeclared payments than first authors (OR 1.64, 95%CI 1.04-2.56). CONCLUSIONS: The majority of studies investigating the use of mesh in ventral hernia repairs and abdominal wall reconstructions did not accurately declare COI. Last authors are at highest risk of undisclosed payments. Current policies on disclosing COI seem to be insufficient to ensure transparency of publications.
引用
- Sekigami Y, Tian T, Char S, et al. Conflicts of Interest in Studies Related to Mesh Use in Ventral Hernia Repair and Abdominal Wall Reconstruction. Ann Surg. 2021. PMID: 33443908. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000004565
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。