上消化道解剖改变患者的内镜与经皮胆道干预:慕尼黑多中心经验
该回顾性多中心研究分析了411例上消化道解剖改变患者行内镜辅助胆道干预的成功率与并发症。至少一次内镜辅助干预成功率为56.9%,Billroth-II/Whipple/Roux-en-Y重建成功率分别为70.5%/56.7%/49.5%,总体并发症率7.1%。经皮胆道引流(PTBD)成功率90.7%、并发症率11.6%,但PTBD患者体能状态更差、胆汁淤积更重且恶性疾病比例更高。
要点
- 内镜辅助胆道干预在解剖改变患者中成功率56.9%,Roux-en-Y重建者最低(49.5%)。
- 内镜辅助干预总体并发症率7.1%,低于PTBD的11.6%。
- PTBD成功率高(90.7%)但适用于体能状态差、胆汁淤积重者。
核心结论
- 上消化道解剖改变患者中内镜辅助胆道干预成功率低于PTBD,但并发症率更优,应尽可能优先尝试内镜。
- 对部分经选择的患者,重复内镜尝试有助于达到目标结果。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2006年3月1日至2014年6月30日德国慕尼黑四家三级内镜中心收治的上消化道解剖改变行胆道干预的患者。
主要发现
- 至少一次内镜辅助胆道干预在234/411例(56.9%)中成功,其中192例首次成功、34例第二次、8例第三次。
- Billroth-II/Whipple/Roux-en-Y重建的成功率分别为70.5%/56.7%/49.5%,并发症率分别为9.3%/6.5%/6.3%。
- 总体并发症率为7.1%;Billroth-II重建且可使用十二指肠镜者成功率最高但并发症率也最高。
- PTBD共置入268次,成功率90.7%、并发症率11.6%,均高于内镜 approach。
- 与内镜治疗患者相比,PTBD患者体能状态更低、胆汁淤积更严重且恶性基础疾病比例显著更高。
临床怎么用
- 对上消化道解剖改变需胆道干预者,应优先尝试内镜辅助方式以降低并发症风险。
- 对Roux-en-Y等长肢重建患者,内镜成功率较低,可考虑重复尝试或转为PTBD。
- PTBD成功率高但并发症风险更高,适用于体能状态差、胆汁淤积重或恶性疾病患者。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计,来自四家三级中心,结果外推需谨慎。
- 研究时段为pre-endosonographic biliary drainage era,未纳入超声内镜引导下胆道引流。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In patients with altered upper gastrointestinal anatomy, conventional endoscopic retrograde cholangiography is often not possible and different techniques, like enteroscopy-assisted or percutaneous approaches are required. Aim of this study was to analyze success and complication rates of these techniques in a large collective of patients in the daily clinical practice in a pre-endosonographic biliary drainage era. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Patients with altered upper gastrointestinal anatomy with biliary interventions between March 1st, 2006, and June 30th, 2014 in four tertiary endoscopic centers in Munich, Germany were retrospectively analyzed. RESULTS: At least one endoscopic-assisted biliary intervention was successful in 234/411 patients (56.9%)-in 192 patients in the first, in 34 patients in the second and in 8 patients in the third attempt. Success rates for Billroth-II/Whipple-/Roux-en-Y reconstruction were 70.5%/56.7%/49.5%. Complication rates for these reconstructions were 9.3%/6.5%/6.3%, the overall complication rate was 7.1%. Success rates were highest in patients with Billroth-II reconstruction where use of a duodenoscope was possible, complication rates were also highest in this scenario. Success rates were lowest in longer-limb anatomy like Roux-en-Y reconstruction. Percutaneous biliary drainages (PTBD) were inserted 268 times with substantially higher success (90.7%) as well as complication rates (11.6%) compared to the endoscopic approach. Compared to patients treated endoscopically, patients with PTBD had a lower performance status, more severe cholestasis and a significant higher rate of malignant underlying disease. CONCLUSION: In patients with altered upper gastrointestinal anatomy, success rates of endoscopic-assisted biliary interventions are lower compared to PTBD. Still, due to the beneficial complication rates of the endoscopic approach, this technique should be preferred whenever possible and in selected patients who still need to be defined in detail, repeated endoscopic attempts are useful to help achieve the desired result.
引用
- Nennstiel S, Freivogel K, Faber A, et al. Endoscopic and percutaneous biliary interventions in patients with altered upper gastrointestinal anatomy-the Munich Multicenter Experience. Surg Endosc. 2021. PMID: 33398586. doi:10.1007/s00464-020-08191-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。