军队医疗系统与民用医院结直肠手术围术期结局与费用比较
本研究基于TRICARE理赔与病历数据,回顾性分析2006至2015年20,317例18-64岁接受结直肠大手术的患者,比较直接医疗与购买医疗的30天结局与费用。结果显示直接医疗再入院 odds 更高、总并发症相似但费用更高;直接医疗体系内高业务量并未减少并发症。
要点
- 直接医疗与购买医疗的总体并发症相似,但直接医疗再入院 odds 更高。
- 直接医疗平均总费用$55,833,高于购买医疗的$30,513。
- 直接医疗体系内,极高业务量机构的平均总费用低于其他机构。
核心结论
- 直接医疗与再入院 odds 升高相关,总体并发症相似,但费用更高。
- 与业务量-质量常见假设相反,直接医疗体系内更高业务量并未与更少并发症相关。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性加权估计方程分析,纳入2006至2015年18-64岁接受结直肠大手术的TRICARE受益人20,317例。
- 比较直接医疗与购买医疗的30天结局(死亡、再入院、主要或次要并发症)及费用(索引费用和包含术后30天的总费用)。
主要发现
- 直接医疗占24.8%;直接医疗与购买医疗平均住院日分别为7.6天与7.7天(P = .24)。
- 调整后30天再入院 odds ratio 为1.40,直接医疗显著更高;总体并发症 odds ratio 为1.05,两者相似。
- 直接医疗与购买医疗平均总费用分别为$55,833与$30,513。
- 直接医疗体系内,极高业务量机构平均总费用为$50,341(95%CI $41,509-$59,173),低于其他机构的$54,869(95%CI $47,822-$61,916)。
临床怎么用
- 在军队医疗系统转诊决策中,需权衡直接医疗再入院 odds 与费用较高、但总体并发症相似的特点。
- 直接医疗体系内不能仅凭业务量推断并发症更少,应关注再入院与费用管理。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: TRICARE military beneficiaries are increasingly referred for major surgeries to civilian hospitals under "purchased care." This loss of volume may have a negative impact on the readiness of surgeons working in the "direct-care" setting at military treatment facilities and has important implications under the volume-quality paradigm. The objective of this study is to assess the impact of care source (direct versus purchased) and surgical volume on perioperative outcomes and costs of colorectal surgeries. METHODS: We examined TRICARE claims and medical records for 18- to 64-year-old patients undergoing major colorectal surgery from 2006 to 2015. We used a retrospective, weighted estimating equations analysis to assess differences in 30-day outcomes (mortality, readmissions, and major or minor complications) and costs (index and total including 30-day postsurgery) for colorectal surgery patients between purchased and direct care. RESULTS: We included 20,317 patients, with 24.8% undergoing direct-care surgery. Mean length of stay was 7.6 vs 7.7 days for direct and purchased care, respectively (P = .24). Adjusted 30-day odds between care settings revealed that although hospital readmissions (odds ratio 1.40) were significantly higher in direct care, overall complications (odds ratio 1.05) were similar between the 2 settings. However, mean total costs between direct and purchased care differed ($55,833 vs $30,513, respectively). Within direct care, mean total costs ($50,341; 95% confidence interval $41,509-$59,173) were lower at very high-volume facilities compared to other facilities ($54,869; 95% confidence interval $47,822-$61,916). CONCLUSION: Direct care was associated with higher odds of readmissions, similar overall complications, and higher costs. Contrary to common assumptions regarding volume and quality, higher volume in the direct-care setting was not associated with fewer complications.
引用
- Haag A, Nabi J, Herzog P, et al. Is the current referral trend a threat to the Military Health System? Perioperative outcomes and costs after colorectal surgery in the Military Health System versus civilian facilities. Surgery. 2021. PMID: 33494947. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2020.12.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。