无症状SARS-CoV-2感染者接受手术的风险模型:术后严重结局与死亡的24个月五地区预测
该研究建立静态和随机两类模型,评估无症状COVID-19感染者接受手术的风险及术后严重肺部并发症和死亡。结论提示无症状感染者手术风险可观,需制定策略避免过度并发症和死亡。
要点
- 无症状COVID-19感染者手术可导致大量术后肺部并发症和死亡。
- 全球预测约120万例肺部并发症和35万例死亡。
核心结论
- 模型显示无症状COVID-19感染者接受手术存在可观的围术期不良结局和死亡风险。
- 疫情期间需制定策略以避免手术后过度并发症和死亡。
研究设计与样本
- 研究建立两套模型:静态模型改变基础感染率和大范围手术率,随机模型考虑COVID-19流行动态和固定人口手术率。
- 通过低和高情景(90%不确定性下限和上限)生成不确定性区间(UI)。
- 建模应用于高收入地区(英国、美国、欧盟无英国)和基于WHO标准人口的全球。
主要发现
- 欧洲模型预测约131,000例(UI 97,000-178,000)肺部并发症和近47,000例死亡(UI 34,000-63,000)。
- 英国模型预测每日无症状感染者手术中位数25至90例,累计约18,700例(UI 13,700-25,300)围术期肺部并发症和6,400例死亡(UI 4,600-8,600)。
- 高收入地区合计预测约259,000例(UI 191,000-351,000)肺部并发症和89,000例死亡(UI 65,000-120,000)。
- 全球预测即使低手术率也约120万例肺部并发症和350,000例死亡。
临床怎么用
- 临床应认识到无症状COVID-19感染者手术的围术期风险,在疫情期间制定策略避免过度并发症和死亡。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To model the risk of admitting silent COVID-19-infected patients to surgery with subsequent risk of severe pulmonary complications and mortality. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: With millions of operations cancelled during the COVID-19 pandemic, pressure is mounting to reopen and increase surgical activity. The risk of admitting patients who have silent SARS-Cov-2 infection to surgery is not well investigated, but surgery on patients with COVID-19 is associated with poor outcomes. We aimed to model the risk of operating on nonsymptomatic infected individuals and associated risk of perioperative adverse outcomes and death. METHODS: We developed 2 sets of models to evaluate the risk of admitting silent COVID-19-infected patients to surgery. A static model let the underlying infection rate (R rate) and the gross population-rate of surgery vary. In a stochastic model, the dynamics of the COVID-19 prevalence and a fixed population-rate of surgery was considered. We generated uncertainty intervals (UIs) for our estimates by running low and high scenarios using the lower and upper 90% uncertainty limits. The modelling was applied for high-income regions (eg, United Kingdom (UK), USA (US) and European Union without UK (EU27), and for the World (WORLD) based on the WHO standard population. RESULTS: Both models provided concerning rates of perioperative risk over a 24-months period. For the US, the modelled rates were 92,000 (UI 68,000-124,000) pulmonary complications and almost 30,000 deaths (UI 22,000-40·000), respectively; for Europe, some 131,000 patients (UI 97,000-178,000) with pulmonary complications and close to 47,000 deaths (UI 34,000-63,000) were modelled. For the UK, the model suggested a median daily number of operations on silently infected ranging between 25 and 90, accumulating about 18,700 (UI 13,700-25,300) perioperative pulmonary complications and 6400 (UI 4600-8600) deaths. In high-income regions combined, we estimated around 259,000 (UI 191,000-351,000) pulmonary complications and 89,000 deaths (UI 65,000-120,000). For the WORLD, even low surgery rates estimated a global number of 1.2 million pulmonary complications and 350,000 deaths. CONCLUSIONS: The model highlights a considerable risk of admitting patients with silent COVID-19 to surgery with an associated risk for adverse perioperative outcomes and deaths. Strategies to avoid excessive complications and deaths after surgery during the pandemic are needed.
引用
- Soreide K, Yaqub S, Hallet J, et al. A Risk Model of Admitting Patients With Silent SARS-CoV-2 Infection to Surgery and Development of Severe Postoperative Outcomes and Death: Projections Over 24 Months for 5 Geographical Regions. Ann Surg. 2021. PMID: 33156071. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000004583
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。