文献速递肝胆胰外科围术期管理与 ERAS

微创肝切除学习曲线的启动、标准化与熟练阶段:专科培训外科医生与先驱及早期采用者的比较

The initiation, standardization and proficiency (ISP) phases of the learning curve for minimally invasive liver resection: comparison of a fellowship-trained surgeon with the pioneers and early adopters.
PubMed 文献 · Surg Endosc · 2020-11-10

本研究应用IDEAL框架和RA-CUSUM曲线,比较一名肝胆胰专科培训(FT)外科医生与微创肝切除先驱(P)及早期采用者(EA)的学习曲线。FT医生在无独立肝手术经验下完成95例微创肝切除,其曲线与EA相似,且倾向处理更大、更恶性的肿瘤,但主要并发症和死亡率无显著差异。

要点

  • FT医生微创肝切除学习曲线与早期采用者相似,尽管无独立肝手术经验。
  • FT医生更倾向选择较大、恶性比例更高的肿瘤,但主要并发症和死亡率未显著增加。
  • ISP模型可能适用于其他创新手术,学习曲线因IDEAL阶段而异。

核心结论

  • 专科培训外科医生的微创肝切除学习曲线与早期采用者相似。
  • FT医生可能倾向处理更大、更恶性的肿瘤及更高ASA分级患者,但主要并发症和死亡率无显著增加。

研究设计与样本

  • 应用IDEAL框架和RA-CUSUM曲线,比较一名FT医生与已发表的P和EA数据。
  • FT定义为无独立手术经验、住院医师后直接进入专科培训的外科医生。
  • 学习曲线分为3阶段:启动(前17或50例)、标准化(第18-46例或1-50例)、熟练(第46、50或135例之后)。
  • 统计分析使用Social Science Statistics软件,显著性定义为p < .05。

主要发现

  • 启动阶段:FT医生处理肿瘤大于EA组(p=0.002),恶性比例94.1%高于P组52.5%(p<0.001)。
  • 标准化阶段:FT医生处理肿瘤大于P组(p=0.004),恶性比例93.1%高于P组(p=0.017),与EA无差异。
  • 熟练阶段:EA组大范围肝切除比例58.7%,高于FT组30.6%(p=0.002)及P组第51-135例35.3%和第135例后44.3%(均p<0.001)。
  • 熟练阶段:FT医生恶性比例高于P组第51-135例(p=0.012),但P组第135例后无差异(p=0.164)。
  • 三组间中转开腹、主要并发症、30天和90天死亡率无统计学显著差异。

临床怎么用

  • 专科培训外科医生可在无独立肝手术经验下安全开展微创肝切除,学习曲线与早期采用者相当。
  • FT医生可能倾向选择更大、更恶性的肿瘤及更高ASA分级患者,但需注意大范围肝切除比例较低。
  • ISP模型可用于评估其他创新手术的学习曲线,根据IDEAL阶段不同曲线各异。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Using the Ideal Development Exploration Assessment and Long-term study (IDEAL) paradigm, Halls et al. created risk-adjusted cumulative sum (RA-CUSUM) curves concluding that Pioneers (P) and Early Adopters (EA) of minimally invasive (MI) liver resection obtained similar results after fewer cases. In this study, we applied this framework to a MI Hepatic-Pancreatic and Biliary fellowship-trained surgeon (FT) in order to assess where along the curves this generation fell. METHODS: The term FT was used to designate surgeons without previous independent operative experience who went from surgical residency directly into fellowship. Three phases of the learning curve were defined using published data on EAs and Ps of MI Hepatectomy, including phase 1 (initiation) (i.e., the first 17 or 50), phase 2 (standardization) (i.e., cases 18-46 or 1-50) and phase 3 (proficiency) (i.e., cases after 46, 50 or 135). Data analysis was performed using the Social Science Statistics software ( www.socscistatistics.com ). Statistical significance was defined as p < .05. RESULTS: From November 2007 until April 2018, 95 MI hepatectomies were performed by a FT. During phase 1, the FT approached larger tumors than the EA group (p = 0.002), that were more often malignant (94.1%) when compared to the P group (52.5%) (p < 0.001). During phase 2, the FT operated on larger tumors and more malignancies (93.1%) when compared to the Ps (p = 0.004 and p = 0.017, respectively). However, there was no difference when compared to the EA. In the phase 3, the EAs tended to perform more major hepatectomies (58.7) when compared to either the FT (30.6%) (p = 0.002) or the P's cases 51-135 and after 135 (35.3% and 44.3%, respectively) (both p values < 0.001). When compared to the Ps cases from 51-135, the FT operated on more malignancies (p = 0.012), but this was no longer the case after 135 cases by the Ps (p = 0.164). There were no statistically significant differences when conversions; major complications or 30- and 90-day mortality were compared among these 3 groups. DISCUSSION: Using the IDEAL framework and RA-CUSUM curves, a FT surgeon was found to have curves similar to EAs despite having no previous independent experience operating on the liver. As in our study, FTs may tend to approach larger and more malignant tumors and do more concomitant procedures in patients with higher ASA classifications than either of their predecessors, without statistically significant increases in major morbidity or mortality. CONCLUSION: It is possible that the ISP (i.e., initiation, standardization, proficiency) model could apply to other innovative surgical procedures, creating different learning curves depending on where along the IDEAL paradigm surgeons fall.

来源:Surg Endosc,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Gumbs AA, Hilal MA, Croner R, et al. The initiation, standardization and proficiency (ISP) phases of the learning curve for minimally invasive liver resection: comparison of a fellowship-trained surgeon with the pioneers and early adopters. Surg Endosc. 2020. PMID: 33174100. doi:10.1007/s00464-020-08122-1

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。