外科医生自我认知对手术技能与减重手术结局的影响:自评与他评对比
该回顾性队列研究纳入25名自愿提交2015至2016年腹腔镜袖状胃切除术视频的外科医生,比较自评与他评手术技能差异,并结合24,186例袖状胃切除术和12,888例胃旁路术数据比较并发症率。结果发现自评与他评比值最高四分位组他评评分更低,且过度自评者在胃旁路术中漏率更高,提示视频评估可识别自我认知差者。
要点
- 外科医生自评技能差异大,自评他评比值高者他评评分更低。
- 过度自评者在更复杂胃旁路术中漏率更高。
- 视频评估可识别自我认知差、或需辅导的外科医生。
核心结论
- 外科医生对自身手术技能的认知差异较大,过度自评者在更复杂手术中漏率更高。
- 视频评估有助于识别自我认知差、可能受益于外科辅导项目的外科医生。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入25名于2015至2016年自愿提交典型腹腔镜袖状胃切除术视频的外科医生。
- 视频采用基于5分Likert量表(5为「大师级外科医生」,1为「培训中外科医生」)的验证工具进行自评和他评。
- 基于24,186例袖状胃切除术和12,888例胃旁路术数据,比较过度自评与低估自评外科医生的风险调整30天并发症率。
主要发现
- 个体总体自评手术技能在2.5至5之间变化。
- 自评他评比值最高四分位组(n=6,比值1.58)总体平均他评评分低于最低四分位组(n=6,比值0.94),分别为2.98 vs 3.79,P=0.0150。
- 袖状胃切除术后最高与最低四分位组并发症率相似,但过度自评者在胃旁路术中漏率更高(0.65 vs 0.27,P=0.0181)。
- 比较组间外科医生经验相似。
临床怎么用
- 可利用手术视频自评与他评对比识别过度自评的外科医生,尤其针对复杂手术如胃旁路术。
- 对自我认知差的外科医生可考虑纳入外科辅导项目以改善结局。
局限性
- 原文未报告研究局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate variation in self versus peer-assessments of surgical skill using surgical videos and compare surgeon-specific outcomes with bariatric surgery. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Prior studies have demonstrated that surgeons with lower peer-reviewed ratings of surgical skill had higher complication rates after bariatric surgery. METHODS: This is a retrospective cohort study of 25 surgeons who voluntarily submitted a video of a typical laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy (SG) between 2015 and 2016. Videos were self and peer-rated using a validated instrument based on a 5-point Likert scale (5= "master surgeon" and 1= "surgeon-in-training"). Risk adjusted 30-day complication rates were compared between surgeons who over-rated and under-rated their skill based on data from 24,186 SG cases and 12,888 gastric bypass (GBP) cases. RESULTS: individual overall self-rating of surgical skill varied between 2.5 and 5. Surgeons in the top quartile for self:peer ratings (n = 6, ratio 1.58) had lower overall mean peer-scores (2.98 vs 3.79, P = 0.0150) than surgeons in the lowest quartile (n = 6, ratio 0.94). Complication rates between top and bottom quartiles were similar after SG, however leak rates were higher with gastric bypass among surgeons who over-rated their skill with SG (0.65 vs 0.27, P = 0.0181). Surgeon experience was similar between comparison groups. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Self-perceptions of surgical skill varied widely. Surgeons who over-rated their skill had higher leak rates for more complex procedures. Video assessments can help identify surgeons with poor self-awareness who may benefit from a surgical coaching program.
引用
- Varban OA, Thumma JR, Carlin AM, et al. Evaluating the Impact of Surgeon Self-awareness by Comparing Self Versus Peer Ratings of Surgical Skill and Outcomes for Bariatric Surgery. Ann Surg. 2020. PMID: 33201111. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000004450
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。