无并发症肝切除术后放置引流增加严重术后并发症率:日本多中心随机对照试验
这项在日本7家机构开展的非盲随机对照试验纳入400例无胆道重建的肝切除患者,比较放置引流(D组199例)与不放置引流(ND组201例)。主要终点为术后90天内Clavien-Dindo Grade 3及以上并发症,D组为8.0%(16/199),ND组为2.5%(5/201),风险差-5.5%(95%CI -9.9%至-1.2%),满足预设非劣效界值4%,且ND组胆漏为0而D组为8.0%(P<0.001)。结论为无并发症肝切除术后不应放置引流。
要点
- 无并发症肝切除术后不放置引流可降低Clavien-Dindo Grade 3及以上并发症率。
- ND组胆漏发生率为0,D组为8.0%(P<0.001)。
- 两组均无术后死亡,各亚组分析均不支持放置引流。
核心结论
- 无并发症肝切除术后不应放置引流。
研究设计与样本
- 非盲随机对照试验,在日本7家机构开展,最终符合方案集分析共400例,D组199例、ND组201例。
- 术中因胆漏或出血风险高排除37例,未纳入最终分析。
主要发现
- Clavien-Dindo Grade 3及以上并发症率D组8.0%(16/199),ND组2.5%(5/201),风险差-5.5%(95%CI -9.9%至-1.2%),满足预设非劣效界值4%。
- 胆漏诊断率D组8.0%(16/199),ND组0%(P<0.001)。
- 两组均无术后死亡。
- 基于8个潜在相关因素划分的亚组中,放置引流均未在Clavien-Dindo Grade 3及以上并发症方面显示优势。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要终点为术后90天内Clavien-Dindo Grade 3及以上并发症。
- 预设非劣效界值为4%,风险差95%CI上限低于4%即确认非劣效。
临床怎么用
- 对于无胆道重建且术中评估胆漏或出血风险不高的肝切除患者,不放置引流。
局限性
- 研究为非盲设计。
- 术中因胆漏或出血风险高排除37例,可能影响外推性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To assess the clinical impact of a no-drain policy after hepatic resection. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Previous randomized controlled trials addressing no-drain policy after hepatic resection seem inconclusive because they did not adopt appropriate study design to validate its true clinical impact. METHODS: This unblinded, randomized controlled trial was done at 7 Japanese institutions. Patients undergoing hepatic resection without biliary reconstruction were randomized to either D group or ND group. When the risk of postoperative bile leakage or hemorrhage were considered high, the patients were excluded during the operation. Primary endpoint was the postoperative complication of C-D grade 3 or higher within 90 postoperative days. A noninferiority of ND group to D group was assessed, and if it was confirmed, a superiority was assessed. RESULTS: Between May 2015 and July 2017, a total of 400 patients were finally included in the per-protocol set analysis: 199 patients in D group and 201 patients in ND group. Intraoperatively, 37 patients were excluded from the final enrollment because of high risk of bile leakage or hemorrhage. Postoperative complication rate of C-D grade 3 or higher was 8.0% (16/199) in the D group and 2.5% (5/201) in the ND group. The risk difference was -5.5% (95% confidence interval: -9.9% to -1.2%) and fulfilled the prescribed noninferiority margin of 4%. No postoperative mortality was experienced in both groups. Bile leakage was diagnosed in 8.0% (16/199) of the D group and none in the ND group (P < 0.001). In none of the subgroups classified based on 8 potentially relevant factors, drain placement was favored in terms of C-D grade 3 or higher complication. CONCLUSIONS: Drains should not be placed after uncomplicated hepatic resections.
引用
- Arita J, Sakamaki K, Saiura A, et al. Drain Placement After Uncomplicated Hepatic Resection Increases Severe Postoperative Complication Rate: A Japanese Multi-institutional Randomized Controlled Trial (ND-trial). Ann Surg. 2021. PMID: 33064385. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000004051
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。