大容量医院标准是否值得腹部肿瘤手术患者的奔波负担?
该研究基于美国国家癌症数据库(2004—2016)49,454例食管、胰腺、直肠癌切除术患者,比较远距离高容量医院(HVH)与本地中容量(IVH)和低容量(LVH)医院的围手术期结局及5年总生存(OS)。结果显示,LVH所有术式30天死亡率高于HVH,IVH仅直肠切除术死亡率更高;IVH和LVH的5年OS均劣于HVH。
要点
- LVH的食管、胰腺、直肠切除术30天死亡率均高于远距离HVH。
- IVH仅直肠切除术30天死亡率高于HVH(OR 1.90,95%CI 1.31-2.75)。
- IVH和LVH的5年OS均劣于HVH,提示本地中容量医院长期结局有待改善。
核心结论
- 与远距离HVH相比,LVH所有术式30天死亡率更高,IVH仅直肠切除术死亡率更高。
- IVH和LVH的5年OS均 consistently 劣于HVH。
研究设计与样本
- 基于美国国家癌症数据库(2004—2016)的回顾性队列研究,共纳入49,454例食管、胰腺或直肠切除术患者。
- 比较远距离HVH(符合容量标准)与本地IVH、LVH的围手术期结局和5年OS。
主要发现
- 17,544例(34.5%)在远距离HVH手术,11,739例(23.7%)在本地IVH,20,171例(40.8%)在本地LVH。
- 至HVH、IVH、LVH的中位(四分位距)旅行距离分别为77.1(51.1-125.4)、13.2(5.8-27.3)、7.8(3.1-15.5)英里。
- 多变量分析显示,LVH所有切除术30天死亡率高于HVH;IVH仅直肠切除术死亡率更高(OR 1.90,95%CI 1.31-2.75)。
- 与HVH相比,IVH(HR 1.25,95%CI 1.19-1.31)和LVH(HR 1.35,95%CI 1.29-1.42)与5年OS降低相关。
临床怎么用
- 对于食管、胰腺、直肠癌切除术,远距离高容量医院可降低30天死亡率和改善5年OS,但需权衡旅行负担。
- 本地中容量医院在直肠切除术的围手术期结局和长期生存方面与高容量医院存在差距,提升其质量可能改善肿瘤治疗可及性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The study objective is to determine the association between travel distance and surgical volume on outcomes after esophageal, pancreatic, and rectal cancer resections. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: "Take the Volume Pledge" aims to centralize esophagectomies, pancreatectomies, and proctectomies to hospitals meeting minimum volume standards. The impact of travel, and possible care fragmentation, on potential benefits of centralized surgery is not well understood. METHODS: Using the National Cancer Database (2004-2016), patients who underwent esophageal, pancreatic, or rectal resections at far HVH meeting volume standards versus local intermediate (IVH) and low-volume (LVH) hospitals were identified. Perioperative outcomes and 5-year OS were compared. RESULTS: Of 49,454 patients, 17,544 (34.5%) underwent surgery at far HVH, 11,739 (23.7%) at local IVH, and 20,171 (40.8%) at local LVH. The median (interquartilerange) travel distances were 77.1 (51.1-125.4), 13.2 (5.8-27.3), and 7.8 (3.1-15.5) miles to HVH, IVH, and LVH, respectively. By multivariable analysis, LVH was associated with increased 30-day mortality for all resections compared to HVH, but IVH was associated with mortality only for proctectomies [odds ratio 1.90, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.31-2.75]. Compared to HVH, both IVH (hazard ratio 1.25, 95% CI 1.19-1.31) and LVH (hazard ratio 1.35, 95% CI 1.29-1.42) were associated with decreased 5-year OS. CONCLUSIONS: Compared to far HVH, 30-day mortality was higher for all resections at LVH, but only for proctectomies at IVH. Five-year OS was consistently worse at local LVH and IVH. Improving long-term outcomes at IVH may provide opportunities for greater access to quality cancer care.
引用
- Song Y, Shannon AB, Concors SJ, et al. Are Volume Pledge Standards Worth the Travel Burden for Major Abdominal Cancer Operations? Ann Surg. 2020. PMID: 33074899. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000004361
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。