美国急诊护理中心依据保险状态延迟急诊外科诊疗
研究通过标准化脚本电话联系美国50州1245家急诊护理中心,模拟需紧急处理的嵌顿性腹股沟疝患者,比较医疗补助与商业保险患者的直接急诊转诊率。结果显示仅约三分之一中心将明显急诊外科病例转诊至急诊,医疗补助患者比商业保险患者更可能被转诊,临床医生分诊者转诊率显著更高但保险差异仍存在。
要点
- 仅约三分之一急诊护理中心将疑似嵌顿疝转诊至急诊。
- 医疗补助患者较商业保险患者更可能被直接转诊至急诊。
- 临床医生分诊时转诊率显著高于非临床人员,但保险差异持续。
核心结论
- 美国仅约三分之一急诊护理中心将明显急诊外科病例转诊至急诊,可能延迟诊疗。
- 医疗补助患者比商业保险患者更可能被直接转诊至急诊。
- 临床医生分诊者转诊率显著更高,但商业保险与医疗补助患者间差异仍存在。
研究设计与样本
- 采用标准化脚本,在50个州随机选取1245家急诊护理中心,于两个时间点各致电一次。
- 调查员分别模拟医疗补助或商业保险的嵌顿性腹股沟疝症状患者。
- 比较不同保险类型的直接急诊转诊率。
主要发现
- 1223家(98.2%)急诊护理中心接受商业保险,981家(78.8%)接受医疗补助。
- 在971家(78.0%)同时接受两种保险的中心,商业保险与医疗补助患者的直接急诊转诊率分别为27.9%和33.8%。
- 医疗补助患者较商业保险患者更可能被转诊至急诊(OR 1.32,95%CI 1.09-1.60)。
- 商业保险患者由临床医生分诊较非临床人员分诊转诊至急诊的可能性高逾6倍(OR 6.46,95%CI 4.63-9.01)。
- 医疗补助患者由临床医生分诊时转诊至急诊的可能性接近9倍(OR 8.72,95%CI 6.19-12.29)。
临床怎么用
- 对疑似嵌顿性腹股沟疝等急诊外科情况,急诊护理中心应建立直接转诊急诊的标准化流程。
- 临床医生参与分诊可提高急诊转诊率,但需关注保险状态相关差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Patients may call urgent care centers (UCCs) with urgent surgical conditions but may not be properly referred to a higher level of care. This study aims to characterize how UCCs manage Medicaid and privately insured patients who present with an emergent condition. METHODS: Using a standardized script, we called 1245 randomly selected UCCs in 50 states on 2 occasions. Investigators posed as either a Medicaid or a privately-insured patient with symptoms of an incarcerated inguinal hernia. Rates of direct emergency department (ED) referral were compared between insurance types. RESULTS: A total of 1223 (98.2%) UCCs accepted private insurance and 981 (78.8%) accepted Medicaid. At the 971 (78.0%) UCCs that accepted both insurance types, direct-to-ED referral rates for private and Medicaid patients were 27.9% and 33.8%, respectively. Medicaid patients were significantly more likely than private patients to be referred to the ED [odds ratio (OR) 1.32, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.09-1.60]. Private patients who were triaged by a clinician compared to nonclinician staff were over 6 times more likely to be referred to the ED (OR 6.46, 95% CI 4.63-9.01). Medicaid patients were nearly 9 times more likely to have an ED referral when triaged by a clinician (OR 8.72, 95% CI 6.19-12.29). CONCLUSIONS: Only one-third of UCCs across the United States referred an apparent emergent surgical case to the ED, potentially delaying care. Medicaid patients were more likely to be referred directly to the ED versus privately insured patients. All patients triaged by clinicians were significantly more likely to be referred to the ED; however, the disparity between private and Medicaid patients remained.
引用
- Hsiang WR, Wiznia D, Yousman L, et al. Urgent Care Centers Delay Emergent Surgical Care Based on Patient Insurance Status in The United States. Ann Surg. 2020. PMID: 32932304. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000004373
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。