教学助理病例最低要求对普通外科住院医师的影响:单中心18年比较
该研究比较了2001至2018学年单中心普通外科住院医师的教学助理(TA)病例数与全国平均水平及第50百分位。2014年ABS实施25例TA最低要求后,本中心TA病例均值从24.9增至46.1,全国第50百分位从24.4增至40.3,均显著增加。结论认为TA病例最低要求有效增加了TA病例数,有望提升住院医师自主性。
要点
- 2014年ABS要求25例TA病例后,本中心与全国TA病例数均显著增加。
- 本中心TA病例以胆道、大肠和疝为主,占59.6%。
- TA病例定义存在较大变异,需ACCME和ABS进一步明确。
核心结论
- 自2014年实施TA病例最低要求以来,本中心与全国TA病例数均出现统计学显著增加,该要求确实产生了效果。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性比较研究,获取2001年7月至2018年6月ACGME病例日志数据,比较本中心项目与全国平均及第50百分位的TA病例数。
主要发现
- 2001-2018学年本中心平均30.1例TA/住院医师,全国第50百分位平均28.1例。
- 2014年前本中心平均24.9例,全国第50百分位24.4例;2014年后本中心46.1例,全国第50百分位40.3例,均显著增加。
- 本中心平均百分位从2014年前的46.4升至2014年后的61.5。
- 2001-2018学年59.6%的TA病例为胆道、大肠和疝,2014年后多个亚类病例显著增加。
关键数值与推荐
- 自2014年起,ABS要求毕业住院医师至少完成25例TA病例方可获得 board certification 资格。
临床怎么用
- TA病例最低要求可促进住院医师自主性,应重视核心手术的TA病例记录与质量。
局限性
- TA病例的定义存在广泛变异,需ACGME和ABS进一步澄清。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Teaching assistant (TA) cases are a training mainstay, due to increased resident autonomy. Since 2014, the American Board of Surgery (ABS) requires a 25 TA case minimum for graduating resident eligibility for board certification. Herein, we analyze our institution's experience compared with the national average, for any change effected by the requirement. STUDY DESIGN: ACGME case log data were obtained for the July 2001 to June 2018 academic years. We compared average TA cases of our program against the national average and national 50th percentile: 2001 to 2014, and 2014 to 2018 academic years. The program TA cases were also broken down by category, with a comparison before and after 2014. Values of p were calculated using a t-test and Mann-Whitney U test. RESULTS: From July 2001 to June 2018, our program averaged 30.1 TA cases/resident, and national 50th percentile average was 28.1. For July 2001 to June 2014 AY (aka pre-2014) and July 2014 to June 2018 AY (aka post-2014) cases per resident, our program averages were 24.9 and 46.1, respectively, and the national 50th percentile averages were 24.4 and 40.3, respectively-both statistically significant increases. Average program percentiles were 46.4 (pre-2014), and 61.5 (post-2014), and 59.6% of program cases logged were biliary, large intestine, and hernia (2001 to 2018 AY), with a statistically significant increase in several case subcategories post-2014. CONCLUSIONS: Teaching assistant cases are an invaluable resource for residents, fostering increased autonomy. Since the 2014 minimum, a statistically significant increase in TA cases was noted in our program and nationally. The majority of sub-categories logged were core procedures. Unequivocally, the TA case minimum requirement has made a difference. This will hopefully lead to increased autonomy and therefore, more comfortable and capable general surgeons. Wide variability is noted in what counts as a TA case, with further clarification needed by the ACGME and ABS.
引用
- Jayanthi P, Patel MB, Mittal V, et al. Effect of Establishing a Teaching Assistant Case Minimum on General Surgery Residents: 18-Year Comparison of a Single Institution to National Data. J Am Coll Surg. 2020. PMID: 32437741. doi:10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2020.04.036
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。