机器人对比腹腔镜腹股沟疝修补术:RIVAL随机临床试验
这项多中心单盲随机对照试验纳入113例单侧原发或复发腹股沟疝患者,最终分析102例,比较机器人或腹腔镜经腹腹膜前修补术。结果显示两组在疼痛、生活质量、伤口并发症等方面无差异,但机器人组手术时间更长、费用更高、术者挫败感更高,且人机工程学无获益。
要点
- 两组在疼痛、生活质量、伤口事件和再入院方面无显著差异。
核心结论
- 对于简单腹股沟疝修补,机器人入路相比腹腔镜入路无临床获益。
- 机器人入路带来更高费用和更长手术时间,并增加术者挫败感,且无助于改善人机工程学。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心、单盲、前瞻性随机对照预试验,2016年4月至2019年4月在6个学术或学术附属中心开展,随访30天。
- 纳入113例单侧原发或复发腹股沟疝患者,排除后102例纳入分析(腹腔镜组54例,机器人组48例)。
主要发现
- 两组在术前、术后1周和30天的伤口事件、再入院、视觉模拟评分疼痛和36项简表健康调查生活质量方面无差异。
- 两组快速上肢评估量表所测术者人机工程学无差异。
临床怎么用
- 对于简单腹股沟疝,腹腔镜经腹腹膜前修补术在费用和手术时间上优于机器人入路,可作为优先选择。
- 机器人入路不应常规用于简单腹股沟疝修补,除非有特定临床情形或研究背景。
局限性
- 本研究为预试验,未设定主要结局指标。
- 样本量较小(共102例分析),随访时间仅30天。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Despite rapid adoption of the robotic platform for inguinal hernia repair in the US, to date, no level I trials have ever compared robotic inguinal hernia repair to laparoscopic repair. This multicenter randomized clinical trial is the first to compare the robotic platform to laparoscopic approach for minimally invasive inguinal hernia repair. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether the robotic approach to inguinal hernia repair results in improved postoperative outcomes compared with traditional laparoscopic inguinal hernia repairs. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This multicenter, single-blinded, prospective randomized clinical pilot study was conducted from April 2016 to April 2019, with a follow-up duration of 30 days in 6 academic and academic-affiliated sites. Enrolled in this study were 113 patients with a unilateral primary or recurrent inguinal hernia. After exclusions 102 remained for analysis. INTERVENTIONS: Standard laparoscopic transabdominal preperitoneal repair or robotic transabdominal preperitoneal repair. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Main outcomes included postoperative pain, health-related quality of life, mobility, wound morbidity, and cosmesis. Secondary outcomes included cost, surgeon ergonomics, and surgeon mental workload. A primary outcome was not selected because this study was designed as a pilot study. The hypothesis was formulated prior to data collection. RESULTS: A total of 102 patients were included in the study (54 in the laparoscopic group, mean [SD] age, 57.2 [13.3] years and 48 [88.9%] male; 48 in the robotic group, mean [SD] age, 56.1 [14.1] years and 44 [91.6%] male). There were no differences at the preoperative, 1-week, or 30-day points between the groups in terms of wound events, readmissions, pain as measured by the Visual Analog Scale, or quality of life as measured by the 36-Item Short Form Health Survey. Compared with traditional laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair, robotic transabdominal preperitoneal repair was associated with longer median (interquartile range) operative times (75.5 [59.0-93.8] minutes vs 40.5 [29.2-63.8] minutes, respectively; P < .001), higher median (interquartile range) cost ($3258 [$2568-$4118] vs $1421 [$1196-$1930], respectively; P < .001), and higher mean (SD) frustration levels on the NASA Task Load Index Scale (range, 1-100, with lower scores indicating lower cognitive workload) (32.7 [23.5] vs 20.1 [19.2], respectively; P = .004). There were no differences in ergonomics of the surgeons between the groups as measured by the Rapid Upper Limb Assessment instrument. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Results of this study showed no clinical benefit to the robotic approach to straightforward inguinal hernia repair compared with the laparoscopic approach. The robotic approach incurred higher costs and more operative time compared with the laparoscopic approach, with added surgeon frustration and no ergonomic benefit to surgeons. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT02816658.
引用
- Prabhu AS, Carbonell A, Hope W, et al. Robotic Inguinal vs Transabdominal Laparoscopic Inguinal Hernia Repair: The RIVAL Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Surg. 2020. PMID: 32186683. doi:10.1001/jamasurg.2020.0034
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。