传统与价值:择期结直肠手术后按方案行术后实验室检查是否有用?
该研究评估择期结直肠手术后常规术后第1天(POD 1)血清实验室检查的临床价值与成本效益。研究纳入2015至2017年2252例患者,共8205项实验室检查值,仅4%异常、1%需主动干预,总费用64000美元。结论认为常规POD 1实验室检查异常率低、干预率更低,不具成本效益,应以临床标准替代按方案检查。
要点
- 择期结直肠手术后常规POD 1实验室检查仅4%异常,1%需主动干预。
- 按方案POD 1实验室检查增加资源利用和费用,不具成本效益。
- 建议以临床标准触发实验室检查,替代常规按方案检查。
核心结论
- 择期结直肠手术后常规POD 1实验室检查很少异常,需主动干预更少,增加资源利用和费用且不具成本效益,应以临床标准替代。
主要发现
- 共8205项实验室检查值,仅4%异常(血红蛋白3%、肌酐6%、钾3%、血糖3%),仅1%被主动干预。
- 这些年份按方案POD 1实验室检查的总费用为64000美元(基于Medicare门诊报销)。
临床怎么用
- 择期结直肠手术后不应常规按方案行POD 1血清实验室检查,应以临床标准触发检查。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Determine if routine ordering of postoperative day 1 (POD 1) serum laboratory tests after elective colorectal surgery are clinically warranted and valuable given the associated costs of these lab tests. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Routine postoperative serum laboratory tests are a part of many colorectal surgery order sets. Whether these protocolized lab tests represent cost-effective care is unknown. METHODS: Patients undergoing elective colorectal surgery between January 1, 2015 and December 31, 2017 at our institution were identified. The protocolized POD 1 lab tests obtained as part of the postoperative order set were reviewed to determine the rate of abnormal values and any intervention in response. Costs associated with protocolized laboratory testing were calculated using dollar amounts representing 2017 outpatient Medicare reimbursement. RESULTS: A total of 2252 patients were identified with 8205 total lab test values. Of these, only 4% were abnormal (3% of hemoglobin values, 6% of creatinine values, 3% of potassium of values, and 3% of glucose values), and only 1% were actively intervened upon. The total aggregate cost of the protocolized POD 1 laboratory tests in these years was $64,000 based on Medicare outpatient reimbursement dollars. CONCLUSIONS: Routine POD 1 lab tests after elective colorectal surgery are rarely abnormal, and they even less frequently require active intervention beyond rechecking. This results in increased resource utilization and cost of care without appreciable impact on clinical care, and is not cost-effective. Protocolized POD 1 laboratory testing should be replaced with clinically-based criteria to trigger serum laboratory investigations.
引用
- McKenna NP, Habermann EB, Glasgow AE, et al. Tradition Versus Value: Is There Utility in Protocolized Postoperative Laboratory Testing After Elective Colorectal Surgery? Ann Surg. 2021. PMID: 31804397. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000003731
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。