文献速递胃肠外科围术期管理与 ERAS

半自动与手动三维重建中央肠系膜血管模型的比较:外科医生的评判

Semi-automated vs. manual 3D reconstruction of central mesenteric vascular models: the surgeon's verdict.
PubMed 文献 · Surg Endosc · 2019-11-19

本研究对24例患者的CT数据集分别采用手动分割(MSM,金标准)和半自动分割(SAM)构建三维血管模型,进行配对比较。定量分析显示SAM在批次1至3有结构改善,异常血管批次4误差指数最高;但定性评估中91.7%的SAM未包含所有对D3右半结肠切除术相关的肠系膜分支。结论认为半自动模型虽定量结果可接受,但定性差异可能在外科手术中造成混淆。

要点

  • 半自动分割模型在91.7%的情况下未能包含所有与D3右半结肠切除术相关的肠系膜分支。
  • 右结肠动脉(RCA)缺失率50%,中结肠动脉(MCA)缺失率29.2%,回结肠动脉(ICA)无缺失。
  • 「完整」血管的管径显著大于「缺失」血管(MCA p<0.001,RCA p=0.016,ICA p<0.001,空肠动脉 p<0.001)。

核心结论

  • 尽管定量分析结果可接受,但定性比较表明半自动生成的三维中央肠系膜血管模型可能在外科手术中造成相当大的混淆。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究纳入正在进行的试验中的24例患者的CT数据集(13例女性,年龄44-77岁),对每例患者分别手动分割和半自动分割构建三维血管模型,共48个模型进行配对比较;手动分割模型(MSM)作为金标准。
  • 数据集分4批(每批6例)交付重建,仅第4批包含解剖异常患者。
  • 评估血管为执行D3右半结肠切除术的外科医生感兴趣的血管,完整性通过配准和距离误差指数定量评估,并通过系统检查定性评估。

主要发现

  • 定量上,半自动分割模型(SAM)从批次1到3显示结构改善;包含异常血管的批次4误差指数最高。
  • 定性上,91.7%的SAM未包含所有与外科医生相关的肠系膜分支。
  • 在SAM中,右结肠动脉(RCA)仅1条(12.5%)评为完整血管,3条(37.5%)评为不完整,4条(50%)缺失。
  • 中结肠动脉(MCA)6条(25%)评为完整,11条(45.8%)不完整,7条(29.2%)缺失;回结肠动脉(ICA)13条(54.2%)完整,11条(45.8%)不完整,无缺失(0%)。
  • 10个(41.7%)SAM包含全部空肠动脉(与MSM相比)。

临床怎么用

  • 半自动三维重建模型目前不宜单独用于D3右半结肠切除术的术前规划或术中导航,需谨慎对待其定性完整性缺陷。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: 3D vascular anatomy roadmaps are currently being implemented for surgical planning and navigation. Quality of the reconstruction is critical. The aim of this article is to compare anatomical completeness of models produced by manual and semi-automatic segmentation. METHODS: CT-datasets from patients included in an ongoing trial, underwent 3D vascular reconstruction applying two different segmentation methods. This produced manually-segmented models (MSMs) and semi-automatically segmented models (SAMs) which underwent a paired comparison. Datasets were delivered for reconstruction in 4 batches of 6, of which only batch 4 contained patients with abnormal anatomy. Model completeness was assessed quantitatively using alignment and distance error indexes and qualitatively with systematic inspection. MSMs were the gold standard. Assessed vessels were those of interest to the surgeon performing D3-right colectomy. RESULTS: 24 CT-datasets (13 females, age 44-77) were used in a paired comparative analysis of 48 3D-models. Quantitatively, SAMs showed structural improvement from Batch 1 to 3. Batch 4, with abnormal vessels, showed the highest error-index values. Qualitatively, 91.7% of SAMs did not contain all mesenteric branches relevant to the surgeon. In SAMs, 1 (12.5%) right colic artery-RCA scored as a complete vessel. 3 (37.5%) RCAs scored as incomplete and 4 (50%) RCAs were absent. 6 (25%) of 24 middle colic arteries-MCA scored as complete vessels. 11 (45.8%) scored as incomplete while 7 (29.2%) MCAs were absent. 13 (54.2%) of 24 ileocolic arteries-ICA were complete vessels. 11 (45.8%) scored as incomplete. None (0%) were absent. Additionally, it was observed that 10 (41.7%) of SAMs contained all their jejunal arteries, when compared to MSMs. Calibers of "complete" vessels were significantly higher than in "missing" vessels (MCA p < 0.001, RCA p = 0.016, ICA p < 0.001, JAs p < 0.001). CONCLUSION: Despite acceptable results from quantitative analysis, qualitative comparison indicates that semi-automatically generated 3D-models of the central mesenteric vasculature could cause considerable confusion at surgery.

来源:Surg Endosc,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Luzon JA, Kumar RP, Stimec BV, et al. Semi-automated vs. manual 3D reconstruction of central mesenteric vascular models: the surgeon's verdict. Surg Endosc. 2019. PMID: 31745632. doi:10.1007/s00464-019-07275-y

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。