文献速递肝胆胰外科

小范围肝切除术:聚焦模糊图景——4471例无肝硬化开放肝切除患者结局分析

Minor Hepatectomies: Focusing a Blurred Picture: Analysis of the Outcome of 4471 Open Resections in Patients Without Cirrhosis.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Surg · 2019-01-01

该多中心回顾性研究纳入17个高容量中心的4471例无肝硬化开放小范围肝切除术(MiH),以左外侧区切除(LLS)和右半肝切除(RH)为参照,发现MiH总体死亡率低但结局异质,部分复杂MiH的严重并发症和胆漏率接近RH。

要点

  • MiH总体90天死亡率0.5%、严重并发症8.6%、肝衰竭2.4%,均低于RH。
  • 复杂核心肝切除胆漏率高于RH(OR=1.94),严重并发症接近RH。
  • 后上段切除、右前区切除和右后区切除的严重并发症与胆漏率与RH相似。

核心结论

  • MiH结局异质,死亡率低但可按严重并发症、胆漏和肝衰竭率分层。
  • 部分MiH的术后结局与右半肝切除相似。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性评估17个高容量中心连续开放肝切除患者。
  • 排除肝硬化和合并消化/胆道切除者,共分析4471例MiH,以LLS(n=442)和RH(n=1042)为参照。
  • 按Brisbane命名分类,并定义复杂LR、后上段切除和复杂核心肝切除。

主要发现

  • MiH与RH相比:90天死亡率0.5%/2.2%,严重并发症8.6%/14.4%,肝衰竭2.4%/11.6%(P<0.001),胆漏率相似。
  • LR与LLS结局相似。
  • 复杂LR和前外侧段Segm/Bisegm的胆漏率高于LLS(OR=2.35和OR=3.24),严重并发症相似。
  • 复杂核心肝切除胆漏率高于RH(OR=1.94),严重并发症接近RH。
  • 后上段切除、右前区切除和右后区切除的严重并发症和胆漏率与RH相似;右前区切除肝衰竭率高于LLS(OR=4.02)。

临床怎么用

  • 小范围肝切除术前应依据切除类型评估严重并发症、胆漏和肝衰竭风险。
  • 复杂核心肝切除、后上段切除及右前后区切除需按接近大范围肝切除的标准进行围术期管理。

局限性

  • 回顾性设计。
  • 仅纳入开放手术且排除肝硬化患者。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To elucidate minor hepatectomy (MiH) outcomes. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Liver surgery has moved toward a parenchyma-sparing approach, favoring MiHs over major resections. MiHs encompass a wide range of procedures. METHODS: We retrospectively evaluated consecutive patients who underwent open liver resections in 17 high-volume centers. EXCLUSION CRITERIA: cirrhosis and associated digestive/biliary resections. Resections were classified as (Brisbane nomenclature): limited resections (LR); (mono)segmentectomies/bisegmentectomies (Segm/Bisegm); right anterior and right posterior sectionectomies (RightAnteriorSect/RightPosteriorSect). Additionally, we defined: complex LRs (ComplexLR = LRs with exposed vessels); postero-superior segmentectomies (PosteroSuperiorSegm = segment (Sg)7, Sg8, and Sg7+Sg8 segmentectomies); and complex core hepatectomies (ComplexCoreHeps = Sg1 segmentectomies and combined resections of Sg4s+Sg8+Sg1). Left lateral sectionectomies (LLSs, n = 442) and right hepatectomies (RHs, n = 1042) were reference standards. Outcomes were adjusted for potential confounders. RESULTS: Four thousand four hundred seventy-one MiHs were analyzed. Compared with RHs, MiHs had lower 90-day mortality (0.5%/2.2%), severe morbidity (8.6%/14.4%), and liver failure rates (2.4%/11.6%, P < 0.001), but similar bile leak rates. LR and LLS had similar outcomes. ComplexLR and Segm/Bisegm of anterolateral segments had higher bile leak rates than LLS rates (OR = 2.35 and OR = 3.24), but similar severe morbidity rates. ComplexCoreHeps had higher bile leak rates than RH rates (OR = 1.94); the severe morbidity rate approached that of RH. PosteroSuperiorSegm, RightAnteriorSect, and RightPosteriorSect had severe morbidity and bile leak rates similar to RH rates. MiHs had low liver failure rates, except RightAnteriorSect (vs LLS OR = 4.02). CONCLUSIONS: MiHs had heterogeneous outcomes. Mortality was low, but MiHs could be stratified according to severe morbidity, bile leak, and liver failure rates. Some MiHs had postoperative outcomes similar to RH.

来源:Ann Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Viganò L, Torzilli G, Troisi R, et al. Minor Hepatectomies: Focusing a Blurred Picture: Analysis of the Outcome of 4471 Open Resections in Patients Without Cirrhosis. Ann Surg. 2019. PMID: 31569127. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000003493

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。