在线外科讨论板是否安全有用?国际疝协作组Facebook群组综述
该研究从国际疝协作组Facebook群组中提取60个连续临床讨论帖,由三名疝专科医生评估建议的安全性、有用性及是否提供循证管理策略。结果显示96.6%的回复安全,但28.4%无用;14条不安全回复中仅4条被纠正。结论认为循证管理常缺失且不安全建议少被质疑。
要点
- 多数回复安全但近三成无用,循证管理策略常未提供。
- 不安全建议常无人纠正,使用在线论坛获取临床建议需谨慎。
- 需建立机制提供循证策略并识别不安全建议以减少患者伤害。
核心结论
- 绝大多数回复被认为有帮助,但循证管理通常未被提供,且不安全建议常未被质疑。
研究设计与样本
- 从国际疝协作组Facebook群组按时间倒序提取60个连续去标识化临床讨论帖,由三名疝专科医生评审。
主要发现
- 60个帖共598条独特回复,每帖中位10条(范围1-26条)。
- 评审正确识别了全部7个正负对照。
- 96.6%的回复安全,28.4%的回复无用。
- 14条回复被认为不安全,但仅4条被纠正。
临床怎么用
- 外科医生使用在线论坛获取临床建议时应保持谨慎,注意循证依据的缺失和不安全建议未被纠正的风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Social media is a growing medium for disseminating information among surgeons. The International Hernia Collaboration Facebook Group (IHC) is a widely utilized social media platform to share ideas and advice on managing patients with hernia-related diseases. Our objective was to assess the safety and utility of advice provided. METHODS: Overall, 60 consecutive de-identified clinical threads were extracted from the IHC in reverse chronological order. A group of three hernia specialists evaluated all threads for unsafe posts, unhelpful comments, and if an established evidence-based management strategy was provided. Positive and negative controls for safe and unsafe answers were included in seven threads and reviewers were blinded to their presence. Reviewers were free to access all online and professional resources (except the IHC). RESULTS: There were 598 unique responses (median 10, 1-26 responses per thread) to the 60 clinical threads/scenarios. The review team correctly identified all seven positive and negative controls. Most responses were safe (96.6%) but some were unhelpful (28.4%). For sixteen threads, the reviewers believed there was an established evidence-based answer; however, only six were provided. In addition, 14 responses were considered unsafe, but only four were corrected. CONCLUSIONS: The vast majority of responses were considered helpful; however, evidence-based management is typically not provided and unsafe recommendations often go uncontested. While the IHC allows wide dissemination of hernia-related surgical advice/discussions, surgeons should be cautious when using the IHC for clinical advice. Mechanisms to provide evidence-based management strategies and to identify unsafe advice are needed to improve quality within online forums and to prevent patient harm.
引用
- Bernardi K, Milton AN, Hope W, et al. Are online surgical discussion boards a safe and useful venue for surgeons to ask for advice? A review of the International Hernia Collaboration Facebook Group. Surg Endosc. 2019. PMID: 31399945. doi:10.1007/s00464-019-06895-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。