文献速递胃肠外科疝与腹壁外科围术期管理与 ERAS

SAGES2018受邀讲者与产业财务关系披露分析

Disclosure at #SAGES2018: An analysis of physician-industry relationships of invited speakers at the 2018 SAGES national meeting.
PubMed 文献 · Surg Endosc · 2019-08-06

该研究审查了2018年SAGES年会526个受邀报告中479个(91%)可获取的视频,比对讲者自我披露与Open Payments Database(OPD)记录。414名讲者(86.4%)报告了披露,但讲者披露与OPD完全一致仅占38.3%(121/315),39%(123/315)存在低报。讲者未披露的产业支付总额达$2,049,535。

要点

  • SAGES2018讲者披露合规率高(86.4%报告披露),但与OPD记录完全一致仅38.3%。
  • 39%的OPD在册讲者存在低报披露,未披露支付总额$2,049,535。
  • 机器人及疝领域获资助最多,分别占40.6%和40.5%。

核心结论

  • SAGES披露规则总体合规性高,但讲者与产业报告的披露之间仍存在差异,包括部分未披露支付且金额可观。
  • 建议调整披露规则,纳入相对补偿金额。

研究设计与样本

  • 审查2018年SAGES年会所有可公开获取的YouTube™报告视频,共526个受邀报告,479个(91%)视频可获取。
  • 对美国医师检索OPD并记录所有>$500的产业支付,将讲者自我披露与OPD记录比对。
  • 报告主题分为十组以确定获资助最多的领域。

主要发现

  • 414名讲者(86.4%)报告了披露;420名唯一讲者中315名列于OPD。
  • 讲者披露与OPD完全一致占38.3%(121/315),低报披露占39%(123/315)。
  • OPD在册讲者的中位支付为$992($0-$374,502),2017年总支付$6,389,097。
  • 讲者未披露的产业支付总额$2,049,535,平均未披露支付$16,662.88(±$40,733.19)。
  • 最大资助方为Intuitive Surgical,支付$1,981,169;机器人与疝领域获资助最多,分别为$2,593,925(40.6%)和$2,591,671(40.5%)。

临床怎么用

  • 外科会议讲者应核对OPD记录以确保披露完整,尤其关注低报风险。
  • 会议组织方可考虑在披露规则中要求报告补偿金额的相对大小。

局限性

  • 仅纳入可公开获取视频的报告,479/526(91%)可获取,可能存在选择偏倚。
  • 仅对美国医师检索OPD,非美国讲者未纳入比对。
  • OPD仅记录>$500的产业支付,低于该阈值的支付未纳入分析。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Financial conflicts of interest (COI) have been shown to affect the interpretation of scientific findings. Publications with unreported COI tend to be more favorable to industry. Since 2014 industry payments to United States (US) physicians are publicly reported in the Open Payments Database (OPD). Several studies show high levels of unreported COI in medical literature; however, there is no research examining COI reporting at surgical conferences. We hypothesized that compliance with the COI disclosure requirement would be high at the 2018 SAGES meeting. However, we expected to find significant discrepancy between speaker-reported and OPD-reported COI. A secondary aim was to characterize the amount, source, and variation in industry payments to invited speakers. METHODS: We reviewed all available presentations from SAGES 2018 as recorded and publicly available on YouTube™ for the presence of COI disclosure and the disclosed industry relationships. For US physicians we searched the OPD and recorded all industry payments > $500. We compared the self-disclosed COI for each speaker with OPD records. Presentation topics were divided into ten groups to determine which topics received the most funding. RESULTS: Of the 526 invited presentations, 479 (91%) videos were available. Disclosures were reported by 414 presenters (86.4%). There were 420 unique presenters of which 315 were listed in the OPD. Speaker-reported disclosures were fully concordant with the OPD in 38.3% (121/315) of cases with 39% (123/315) under-reporting disclosures. Of presenters listed in OPD, the median payment was $992 ($0-$374,502) with a total of $6,389,097 paid in 2017. SAGES speakers failed to disclose $2,049,535 worth of industry payments with an average undisclosed payment of $16,662.88 (± $40,733.19). The largest financial contributor was Intuitive Surgical with $1,981,169 paid. Among topics, robotics and hernia received the most funding with $2,593,925 (40.6%) and $2,591,671 (40.5%) paid, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Overall compliance with SAGES disclosure rules is high. There remains a discrepancy between speaker- and industry-reported disclosures, including a number of undisclosed payments, some of which are substantial. Adjustments to disclosure rules to include the relative amount of compensation may be warranted.

来源:Surg Endosc,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lois AW, Ehlers AP, Minneman J, et al. Disclosure at #SAGES2018: An analysis of physician-industry relationships of invited speakers at the 2018 SAGES national meeting. Surg Endosc. 2019. PMID: 31388810. doi:10.1007/s00464-019-07037-w

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。