SAGES高级胃肠与微创外科专科培训重新设计:试点结果与新标准采纳
试点显示学员在前肠病例达标率显著更高,但在肝胆胰/实体器官/结直肠/胸科病例达标率显著更低;据此SAGES删除了该类别,并与FC合作分阶段实施其余标准。
要点
- 试点学员前肠病例达标率显著高于历史对照,肝胆胰/实体器官/结直肠/胸科达标率显著更低。
- 试点项目与非试点项目在2016-2017年各定义类别最低量达标上无统计学差异。
- SAGES据此删除肝胆胰/实体器官/结直肠/胸科类别,其余标准分3年逐步实施。
核心结论
- 试点研究提供了可行性和可推广性证据,支持纳入适当定义类别以建立新的高级胃肠与微创外科专科培训标准。
研究设计与样本
- 将试点项目2016-2017年病例日志与其他所有高级胃肠与微创外科项目(n=92)比较以评估可推广性。
- 将试点学员2017-2018年病例日志与3年历史学员病例日志(n=326)比较以评估可行性,使用Fisher精确检验,p<0.05为显著。
主要发现
- 16名试点学员有完整数据,每名学员中位251.5例高级微创病例和62.5例内镜。
- 根据2016-2017年数据,试点项目与非试点项目在任何定义类别最低量达标上均无统计学差异。
- 与历史对照相比,2017-2018年试点学员在前肠病例达到定义类别最低量的可能性显著更高。
- 试点学员在减重、腹股沟疝、腹壁疝和内镜的最低量达标上呈现非显著更高趋势。
- 试点学员在肝胆胰/实体器官/结直肠/胸科病例达到最低量的可能性显著更低。
关键数值与推荐
- SAGES删除了肝胆胰/实体器官/结肠/胸科类别,并与FC合作批准其余标准在3年内分阶段实施。
临床怎么用
- 新的高级胃肠与微创外科专科培训标准将分阶段实施,外科培训项目可据此调整病例记录和培训重点。
局限性
- 试点项目由担任SAGES领导职务的项目主任自愿参与,可能存在选择偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: SAGES is responsible for defining educational content for Advanced GI/MIS fellowships administered through the fellowship council (FC). In Fall 2016, to better define core content contained in these fellowships, SAGES proposed new case log criteria including minimum volumes within six defined categories. To test feasibility of these criteria, SAGES conducted a pilot study during the 2017-2018 academic year. METHODS: Advanced GI/MIS fellowship programs directors (PD's) who also held leadership roles in SAGES were invited to participate in the pilot. Fourteen programs including 17 fellows volunteered. To assess generalizability, 2016-2017 case log data for the volunteered pilot programs were compared to all other advanced GI/MIS programs (n = 92). To assess feasibility of the new criteria, pilot programs' 2017-2018 case logs were compared to 3 years of historical fellows' case logs (n = 326). Fisher's exact test was used for comparisons with p < 0.05 considered significant. RESULTS: Complete data were available for 16 pilot fellows (median 251.5 advanced MIS cases and 62.5 endoscopies per fellow). According to 2016-2017 data, pilot programs were not statistically different from non-pilot programs regarding achievement of any defined category minimum. Compared to historical controls, the 2017-2018 pilot fellows were significantly more likely to meet the defined category minimum for foregut cases and demonstrated a non-significant trend toward higher achievement of minimums for bariatrics, inguinal hernia, ventral hernia, and endoscopy. Pilot fellows were significantly less likely to meet the minimum for HPB/solid organ/colorectal/thoracic cases. Based on these data, SAGES eliminated the HPB/solid organ/colon/thoracic category and, in partnership with the FC, approved staged implementation of the remaining criteria over 3 years. CONCLUSIONS: The pilot study provided feasibility and generalizability evidence that allowed inclusion of appropriate defined categories for establishment of the new Advance GI/MIS fellowship criteria. We anticipate that the revised criteria will enhance the educational benefit of these fellowships.
引用
- Weis JJ, Goldblatt M, Pryor A, et al. SAGES Advanced GI/MIS fellowship redesign: pilot results and adoption of new standards. Surg Endosc. 2019. PMID: 31190226. doi:10.1007/s00464-019-06899-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。