微创结肠切除术与开腹手术的围术期结局及资源利用对比
基于Premier医疗数据库的回顾性研究,纳入2010年至2017年择期住院结肠切除术患者134,970例,采用倾向评分1:1匹配比较微创手术(MIS,腹腔镜/机器人)与开腹手术(OS)的临床与经济结局。匹配后左侧46,708例、右侧44,560例,MIS组吻合口漏、出血、感染风险均更低,住院时间更短、总费用更低,但手术时间更长;MIS比例由2010年约2%升至2017年19–23%,主要由机器人手术增长驱动。
要点
- MIS结肠切除术吻合口漏、出血、感染风险均低于开腹手术(均p<0.001)。
- MIS住院时间更短、总住院费用更低,但手术室时间更长。
- MIS比例由2010年约2%升至2017年19–23%,主要来自机器人手术的>十倍增长。
核心结论
- 与开腹手术相比,MIS结肠切除术与主要围术期并发症(包括吻合口漏)风险更低、住院时间更短、总住院费用更低相关,尽管手术时间更长。
- MIS结肠切除术比例随时间上升,近期增长似由机器人手术的采用推动。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性Premier医疗数据库研究,纳入2010年1月1日至2017年9月30日择期住院结肠切除术患者,以首次入院为索引入院。
- 按MIS(腹腔镜/机器人)或OS分组,并分左半与右半结肠切除术;采用1:1倾向评分匹配处理患者/医院/提供者特征的潜在混杂。
- 研究共纳入134,970例符合条件患者;匹配后MIS与OS组左半共46,708例、右半共44,560例。
主要发现
- 左半结肠:吻合口漏MIS 7.9% vs OS 9.9%;出血7.8% vs 9.7%;感染3.3% vs 5.8%;感染/吻合口漏复合9.8% vs 13.3%。
- 右半结肠:吻合口漏8.9% vs 11.1%;出血9.8% vs 10.8%;感染3.0% vs 5.1%;感染/吻合口漏复合10.5% vs 10.4%。
- 手术室时间:左半MIS 240.8 min vs OS 216.2 min;右半192.8 min vs 178.0 min。
- 住院时间:左半5.4 vs 7.1天;右半5.5 vs 7.1天;总住院费用:左半$18,564 vs $19,960;右半$17,375 vs $19,417(均p<0.001)。
- MIS比例由2010年约2%升至2017年19–23%,由机器人手术>十倍增长驱动。
关键数值与推荐
- 吻合口漏、出血、感染及感染/吻合口漏复合风险在MIS组均低于OS组(均p<0.001)。
- MIS组手术室时间更长、住院时间更短、总住院费用更低(均p<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 择期结肠切除术可优先考虑MIS(腹腔镜/机器人)以降低吻合口漏等主要围术期并发症、缩短住院并降低总费用。
- 应权衡MIS手术时间更长的特点,在机器人手术逐渐普及的趋势下合理配置资源与选择术式。
局限性
- 为回顾性数据库研究,虽采用倾向评分匹配,仍可能存在未测量混杂。
- 结局仅限索引入院期间测量,未涵盖远期结局。
- 数据来自Premier医疗数据库,外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: We used a population-based database to: (1) compare clinical and economic outcomes between minimally invasive surgery (MIS) and open surgery (OS) for colectomy; and (2) evaluate contemporary trends in MIS rates. METHODS: Retrospective Premier Healthcare Database review of patients undergoing elective inpatient colectomy between January 1, 2010 and September 30, 2017 (first = index admission). Patients were classified into MIS (laparoscopic/robotic) or OS groups, and by left or right colectomy. Propensity score matching (1:1 ratio) of MIS and OS groups was used to address potential confounding from patient/hospital/provider characteristics. Study outcomes, measured during index admission, included major perioperative complications [anastomotic leak (AL), bleeding, infection, and a composite of infection/AL], operating room time (ORT), length of stay (LOS), and total hospital costs. RESULTS: Among 134,970 study-eligible patients, MIS rates increased from ~ 2% (2010) to 19-23% (2017), driven by a > tenfold increase in robotic surgery. The matched MIS and OS colectomy groups comprised 46,708 (left) and 44,560 (right) total patients. Risks of AL, bleeding, and infection were lower for MIS versus OS (all p < 0.001). In left: AL occurred in 7.9% of MIS versus 9.9% of OS; bleeding 7.8% versus 9.7%; infection 3.3% versus 5.8%; infection/AL 9.8% versus 13.3%. In right: AL 8.9% versus 11.1%; bleeding 9.8% versus 10.8%; infection 3.0% versus 5.1%; infection/AL 10.5% versus 10.4%. Although ORTs were longer with MIS (left: 240.8 vs. 216.2 min; right: 192.8 vs. 178.0 min), LOS was shorter (left: 5.4 vs. 7.1 days; right: 5.5 vs. 7.1 days), and total hospital costs were lower (left: $18,564 vs. $19,960; right: $17,375 vs. $19,417) versus OS (all p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Compared with OS, MIS was associated with significantly lower risk of major perioperative complications (including AL), lower LOS, and lower total hospital costs, despite longer OR times. MIS colectomy rates have increased over time; recent gains appear to be due to uptake of robotic surgery.
引用
- Wei D, Johnston S, Goldstein L, et al. Minimally invasive colectomy is associated with reduced risk of anastomotic leak and other major perioperative complications and reduced hospital resource utilization as compared with open surgery: a retrospective population-based study of comparative effectiveness and trends of surgical approach. Surg Endosc. 2019. PMID: 31089882. doi:10.1007/s00464-019-06805-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。