危地马拉短期外科任务对医生执业影响的定性研究
本研究通过滚雪球抽样访谈22名危地马拉本地医生和13名外国来访医生,探讨短期外科任务(STM)对医疗实践的影响。结果显示,STM影响外科 care 的提供,涉及技能使用、并发症管理、围术期 care 和医患信任;本地医生认为STM对其职业有净收益但非完美解决方案,外国医生则获得高个人满足感。
要点
- STM影响本地与外国医生的外科实践,包括技能使用与并发症管理。
- 本地医生认为STM对职业有净收益,但错失本地能力建设机会。
- 外国医生认为成本可控且个人满意度高,建议加强可持续教育。
核心结论
- 本地医生报告STM对其职业有净收益,但认为STM是未满足外科需求的不完美解决方案。
- 外国医生描述成本可控且对STM工作有高个人满意度。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究,采用滚雪球抽样访谈22名危地马拉本地医生和13名外国来访医生。
- 访谈逐字转录、迭代编码并分析以识别新兴主题,通过三角验证和寻找反证验证发现。
主要发现
- 识别出两个主要领域:STM环境下的实践影响外科 care 的提供,以及参与STM的专业和经济影响。
- 与常规实践的差异表现为偶尔不适当的技能使用、术后并发症管理、围术期 care 与「纯手术」的实践对比,以及对医患沟通和信任的影响。
- 本地医生描述了错失发展本地能力的机会,例如通过教育和优化资源规划。
- 外国医生描述了成本可控和对STM工作的高个人满意度。
临床怎么用
- STM可通过加强与本地医生的合作关系和优先考虑可持续教育努力来增强其影响。
- 应关注STM环境中技能使用、并发症管理和医患沟通的差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To explore the impact of short-term surgical missions (STMs) on medical practice in Guatemala as perceived by Guatemalan and foreign physicians. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: STMs send physicians from high-income countries to low and middle-income countries to address unmet surgical needs. Although participation among foreign surgeons has grown, little is known of the impact on the practice of foreign or local physicians. METHODS: Using snowball sampling, we interviewed 22 local Guatemalan and 13 visiting foreign physicians regarding their perceptions of the impact of Guatemalan STMs. Interviews were transcribed verbatim, iteratively coded, and analyzed to identify emergent themes. Findings were validated through triangulation and searching for disconfirming evidence. RESULTS: We identified 2 overarching domains. First, the delivery of surgical care by both Guatemalan and foreign physicians was affected by practice in the STM setting. Differences from usual practice manifested as occasionally inappropriate utilization of skills, management of postoperative complications, the practice of perioperative care versus "pure surgery," and the effect on patient-physician communication and trust. Second, both groups noted professional and financial implications of participation in the STM. CONCLUSIONS: While Guatemalan physicians reported a net benefit of STMs on their careers, they perceived STMs as an imperfect solution to unmet surgical needs. They described missed opportunities for developing local capacity, for example through education and optimal resource planning. Foreign physicians described costs that were manageable and high personal satisfaction with STM work. STMs could enhance their impact by strengthening working relationships with local physicians and prioritizing sustainable educational efforts.
引用
- Coughran AJ, Merrell SB, Pineda C, et al. Local and Visiting Physician Perspectives on Short Term Surgical Missions in Guatemala: A Qualitative Study. Ann Surg. 2021. PMID: 31009390. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000003292
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。