文献速递胃肠外科肝胆胰外科甲状腺与颈部外科

机器人手术系统评价与Meta分析的质量评价与重叠调查

Replicate systematic review and meta-analyses on robotic surgery: a quality appraisal and overlap investigation.
PubMed 文献 · Surg Endosc · 2019-04-10

该研究检索MEDLINE、EMBASE和Cochrane Library至2017年8月1日,纳入90篇机器人手术相关Meta分析,用PRISMA和AMSTAR评估质量并调查重叠程度。平均报告质量得分22.5(83.2%),方法学质量得分7.6(69.2%);大学附属机构作者和有统计学家或流行病学家合著者与更好的报告质量相关。重叠最多的主题包括机器人甲状腺切除术、前列腺切除术、胃切除术、结肠切除术和胃底折叠术。

要点

  • 机器人手术Meta分析数量增长但质量欠佳,平均报告质量83.2%、方法学质量69.2%。
  • 大学附属机构作者及有统计学家或流行病学家合著者的Meta分析报告质量更好。
  • 同一主题存在大量重叠Meta分析,36篇(40%)引用了同主题既往Meta分析。

核心结论

  • 同一主题下开展多个重叠且结论相同、质量欠佳的Meta分析可能浪费资源和精力。
  • 大学附属机构作者及流行病学和统计学专家更可能开展更高质量的Meta分析。
  • 需要更多指南和注册平台以避免重叠的Meta分析。

研究设计与样本

  • 检索MEDLINE、EMBASE和Cochrane Library数据库至2017年8月1日。
  • 纳入90篇机器人手术相关Meta分析,覆盖5个外科亚专科。
  • 使用PRISMA和AMSTAR清单评估报告和方法学质量,并调查重叠程度。

主要发现

  • 平均报告质量得分为22.5(83.2%),平均方法学质量得分为7.6(69.2%)。
  • 大学附属机构作者和有统计学家或流行病学家合著者与更好的报告质量得分相关。
  • 重叠Meta分析最多的主题(均≥6篇)为机器人辅助甲状腺切除术、前列腺切除术、胃切除术、结肠切除术和胃底折叠术。
  • 36篇(40%)纳入的Meta分析引用了同主题既往Meta分析。
  • 在7篇比较机器人辅助根治性前列腺切除术与开放手术的Meta分析中,多数(6/7)得出相同结论;该主题50%至86%的Meta分析纳入了相同的试验作为原始研究。

临床怎么用

  • 开展机器人手术Meta分析前应检索注册平台以避免与已有同主题研究重叠。
  • 建议纳入统计学家或流行病学家作为合著者以提升方法学质量。
  • 临床解读机器人手术Meta分析时需注意其方法学质量可能欠佳及重叠偏倚。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The number of publications of systematic reviews and meta-analyses (MAs) on robotic surgery have been increasing, including many investigating the same topic. Their quality and extent of overlap remains unclear. We assessed the quality of the MAs in this area and investigated the extent of their overlap. METHODS: Relevant studies were identified by searching the MEDLINE, EMBASE, and Cochrane Library databases up to August 1, 2017. Reporting and methodological quality levels were assessed using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) and Assessment of Multiple Systematic Reviews (AMSTAR) checklists. A thorough investigation of the extent of overlap was performed. RESULTS: In total, 90 MAs in 5 surgical subspecialties were included after full-text review. The mean reporting and methodological quality scores were 22.5 (83.2%) and 7.6 (69.2%), respectively. Authors from university-affiliated institutions and the presence of statistician or epidemiologist coauthors were associated with better-reporting quality scores. The topics with the most overlapping MAs (all ≥ 6) were robot-assisted thyroidectomy, prostatectomy, gastrectomy, colectomy, and fundoplication. 36 (40%) of the included MAs cited previous MAs on the same topic. Among the 7 MAs comparing robot-assisted radical prostatectomy to the open procedure, most (6/7) drew the same conclusion. 50 to 86% of MAs on this topic included the same trials as primary studies. CONCLUSION: Conducting multiple overlapping MAs with identical conclusions on the same topic that are of suboptimal quality may be a waste of resource and effort. Authors from university-affiliated institutes and experts in epidemiology and statistics are more likely to conduct MAs that have better quality. More guidelines and registries are needed to avoid overlapping MAs.

来源:Surg Endosc,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ji J, Zhang H, Xu D, et al. Replicate systematic review and meta-analyses on robotic surgery: a quality appraisal and overlap investigation. Surg Endosc. 2019. PMID: 30972621. doi:10.1007/s00464-019-06780-4

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。