外科模拟继续教育课程中导师教学指令的差异分析
本研究分析为期两年的腹腔镜疝修补模拟继续教育课程中12名外科导师的教学对话,58名学员按自报经验分组。导师对相对专家更多以轶事回应,对新手更多以「不应做什么」回应;线性回归显示经验较少学员的模拟进展与「不应做什么」频率显著相关。课后访谈证实导师持续评估学员并调整教学策略。
要点
- 导师对经验丰富学员多用轶事性回应,对新手多用「不应做什么」的纠正性指令。
- 经验较少学员随模拟进展,导师「不应做什么」指令频率显著增加。
- 导师在整个课程中持续评估学员并动态调整教学策略。
核心结论
- 导师根据学员自报经验水平、对学员需求的评估及学员在训练中的进展,显著调整教学重点。
研究设计与样本
- 收集2年内12名外科导师在腹腔镜疝修补模拟继续教育课程中的音视频数据,58名学员按自报腹腔镜和疝修补经验分组,对导师对话转录进行自动编码并统计分析,辅以课后访谈定性验证。
主要发现
- t检验显示导师对相对专家更可能以轶事编码回应,对新手更可能以「不应做什么」编码回应。
- 线性回归显示经验较少学员的模拟标准化进展与「不应做什么」编码频率之间存在显著关系。
- 课后访谈显示导师在整个课程中持续评估参与者并调整教学策略。
临床怎么用
- 在模拟继续教育课程中,导师可依据学员经验水平差异化使用轶事与「不应做什么」的指令,并随模拟进展动态调整教学重点。
局限性
- 原文未报告样本量以外的局限性信息。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Interest is growing in simulation-based continuing medical education courses for practicing surgeons. However, little research has explored the instruction employed during these courses. This study examines instruction practices used during an annual simulation-based continuing medical education course. METHODS: Audio-video data were collected from surgeon instructors (n = 12) who taught a simulated laparoscopic hernia repair continuing medical education course across 2 years. Surgeon learners (n = 58) were grouped by their self-reported laparoscopic and hernia repair experience. Instructors' transcribed dialogue was automatically coded for 5 types of responses to the following questions: anecdotes, confirming, correcting, guidance, and what not to do. Differences in these responses were measured against the progress of the simulations and across learners with different experience levels. Postcourse interviews with instructors were conducted for additional qualitative validation. RESULTS: Performing t tests of instructor responses revealed that they were significantly more likely to answer in forms coded as anecdotes when responding to relative experts and in forms coded as what not to do when responding to novices. Linear regressions of each code against normalized progressions of each simulation revealed a significant relationship between progression through a simulation and frequency of the what not to do code for less-experienced learners. Postcourse interviews revealed that instructors continuously assess participants throughout a session and modify their teaching strategies. CONCLUSION: Instructors significantly modified the focus of their teaching as a function both of their learners' self-reported experience levels, their assessment of learner needs, and learner progression through the training sessions.
引用
- Godfrey M, Rosser AA, Pugh CM, et al. Teaching practicing surgeons what not to do: An analysis of instruction fluidity during a simulation-based continuing medical education course. Surgery. 2019. PMID: 30876670. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2019.01.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。