EAES单孔内镜手术共识声明解读
欧洲内镜外科协会(EAES)于2017年基于系统检索文献制定单孔内镜手术(SIES)共识,采用牛津2011证据分级和GRADE推荐。共识指出该领域缺乏高级别证据和长期随访,在选定患者中SIES围术期安全有效,美容满意度是主要优势,疼痛优势不一致,考虑成本和学习曲线应仅在明确获益后推广。
要点
- SIES在选定患者中围术期安全有效,美容满意度是主要优势。
- SIES疼痛优势相比传统腹腔镜未一致证实,证据级别有限。
- 因直接成本增加和学习曲线延长,应仅在明确获益后推广SIES。
核心结论
- SIES领域缺乏高级别证据和长期随访,在选定患者中安全有效,美容满意度为主要优势。
- 疼痛优势未一致证实,考虑成本和学习曲线应仅在明确获益后推广。
研究设计与样本
- EAES专家小组基于预设方案系统检索文献,于2017年6月16日法兰克福EAES大会共识会议制定。
- 证据按牛津2011证据分级,推荐按GRADE标准,涵盖一般、器官特异性和新进展三个主题。
主要发现
- SIES在选定患者中围术期安全有效。
- 美容满意度是SIES的主要优势,疼痛优势未一致证实。
关键数值与推荐
- SIES领域缺乏高级别证据和长期随访。
- 考虑直接成本增加(器械、设备、手术时间)和学习曲线延长,应仅在明确获益后推广。
临床怎么用
- 在选定患者中可考虑SIES,需权衡美容获益与成本和学习曲线。
- 推广SIES应基于明确获益的证明。
局限性
- 缺乏高级别证据和长期随访。
- 疼痛优势未一致证实。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Laparoscopic surgery changed the management of numerous surgical conditions. It was associated with many advantages over open surgery, such as decreased postoperative pain, faster recovery, shorter hospital stay and excellent cosmesis. Since two decades single-incision endoscopic surgery (SIES) was introduced to the surgical community. SIES could possibly result in even better postoperative outcomes than multi-port laparoscopic surgery, especially concerning cosmetic outcomes and pain. However, the single-incision surgical procedure is associated with quite some challenges. METHODS: An expert panel of surgeons has been selected and invited to participate in the preparation of the material for a consensus meeting on the topic SIES, which was held during the EAES congress in Frankfurt, June 16, 2017. The material presented during the consensus meeting was based on evidence identified through a systematic search of literature according to a pre-specified protocol. Three main topics with respect to SIES have been identified by the panel: (1) General, (2) Organ specific, (3) New development. Within each of these topics, subcategories have been defined. Evidence was graded according to the Oxford 2011 Levels of Evidence. Recommendations were made according to the GRADE criteria. RESULTS: In general, there is a lack of high level evidence and a lack of long-term follow-up in the field of single-incision endoscopic surgery. In selected patients, the single-incision approach seems to be safe and effective in terms of perioperative morbidity. Satisfaction with cosmesis has been established to be the main advantage of the single-incision approach. Less pain after single-incision approach compared to conventional laparoscopy seems to be considered an advantage, although it has not been consistently demonstrated across studies. CONCLUSIONS: Considering the increased direct costs (devices, instruments and operating time) of the SIES procedure and the prolonged learning curve, wider acceptance of the procedure should be supported only after demonstration of clear benefits.
引用
- Morales-Conde S, Peeters A, Meyer YM, et al. European association for endoscopic surgery (EAES) consensus statement on single-incision endoscopic surgery. Surg Endosc. 2019. PMID: 30771069. doi:10.1007/s00464-019-06693-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。