复杂腹壁疝修补中技术与补片类型的影响:前瞻性随机多中心对照试验
该前瞻性随机多中心对照试验纳入120例复杂腹壁疝患者,随机比较覆盖法(前入路组织分离)与底层法(后入路组织分离)以及人脱细胞真皮(HADM)与猪脱细胞真皮(PADM)补片对结局的影响。结果显示1年复发率在补片位置或类型间无显著差异,但覆盖法组手术部位感染率更低且早期生活质量评分更优。
要点
- 补片位置(覆盖法 vs 底层法)和补片类型(HADM vs PADM)对1年疝复发率无显著影响。
- 覆盖法组手术部位感染率显著低于底层法组(1.6% vs 11.9%,p=0.03)。
- 覆盖法组术后早期躯体功能评分和角色限制评分更优,12个月内躯体功能评分最高。
核心结论
- 补片解剖位置或类型不影响复杂腹壁疝修补后的复发率。
- 覆盖法技术相比底层法具有更低的感染率和更好的早期生活质量优势。
- HADM与PADM临床结局相似,非劣效,与先前文献相反。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性随机多中心对照试验,在3个中心纳入120例患者。
- 随机分组比较覆盖法(前入路组织分离)与底层法(后入路组织分离)及补片类型(HADM vs PADM)。
- 关键纳入标准包括疝大小>200 cm2、BMI<40 kg/m2、HbA1C<7%、戒烟>6周且实现筋膜原发闭合。
- 主要结局为1年疝复发,由独立检查者/影像学确定。
- 进行标准化研究者培训,包括猪模型和首例手术由主要研究者监督。
主要发现
- 四组人口学特征无显著差异(年龄60±12岁,BMI 32±5 kg/m2,女性51%)。
- 总体1年复发率为10.8%。
- 补片位置组复发率无显著差异(覆盖法9.8%,底层法11.9%)。
- 补片类型组复发率无显著差异(HADM 10.3%,PADM 11.3%)。
- 覆盖法组手术部位感染率显著更低(1.6% vs 11.9%,p=0.03),且早期术后躯体功能(p=0.001)和角色限制评分(p=0.04)更优,12个月内躯体功能评分最高(p<0.03)。
临床怎么用
- 复杂腹壁疝修补中,补片位置和类型的选择可不影响复发率,但覆盖法可能降低感染风险并改善早期生活质量。
- HADM与PADM可互换使用,临床结局相似。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: To our knowledge, there is an absence of prospective randomized multicenter controlled trials evaluating both the impact of technique and mesh type on outcomes in complicated ventral hernia repair. STUDY DESIGN: A prospective randomized multicenter controlled trial of 120 patients at 3 sites was conducted in which patients were randomized to either overlay (anterior component separation) or underlay mesh placement (posterior component separation) and mesh type (human acellular dermis [HADM] vs porcine acellular dermis [PADM]). Key inclusion criteria included hernia size (>200 cm2), BMI < 40 kg/m2, hemoglobin A1C < 7%, tobacco free > 6 weeks and primary fascial closure. Primary outcome was hernia recurrence at 1 year, determined by independent examiner/imaging. Secondary outcomes included complications and patient satisfaction (short form [SF]-36v2). Standardized investigator training included a porcine model followed by a proctored first case by the lead investigator. RESULTS: There were no significant differences in demographics between the 4 groups (age 60 ±12 years, BMI 32 ± 5 kg/m2, 51% female). The overall 1-year recurrence rate was 10.8%. There was no significant difference in recurrence rate by location of mesh placement (overlay 9.8%, underlay 11.9%) or mesh type (HADM 10.3%, PADM 11.3%). Overlay patients had a significantly lower surgical site infection rate (1.6% vs 11.9% p = 0.03), reported better physical functioning (p = 0.001) and role limitation scores (p = 0.04) in the early postoperative period, and achieved the highest physical functioning score during the 12-month period (p < 0.03). CONCLUSIONS: Recurrence rates were not affected by either anatomic location or type of mesh used. To our knowledge, this represents the first prospective randomized multicenter controlled trial that demonstrates similar clinical outcomes using HADM vs PADM (not inferiority, contrary to previously published literature), with several advantages identified using the overlay technique.
引用
- Bochicchio GV, Garcia A, Kaufman J, et al. Evaluating the Impact of Technique and Mesh Type in Complicated Ventral Hernia Repair: A Prospective Randomized Multicenter Controlled Trial. J Am Coll Surg. 2019. PMID: 30707935. doi:10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2019.01.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。