文献速递围术期管理与 ERAS

手术安全核查表实施与使用挑战的混合方法研究

A mixed methods study of challenges in the implementation and use of the surgical safety checklist.
PubMed 文献 · Surgery · 2018-11-24

该研究在儿科学术医院对51台手术观察手术安全核查表的依从性与质量,发现医院记录的依从性(简报94%、暂停100%、汇报100%)远高于实际核查条目完成比例(26%、59%、42%)。访谈18名医护人员提示,自上而下的强制要求、感知获益不足及与其他流程冗余导致核查沦为「打勾练习」,掩盖了潜在安全效益。

要点

  • 医院记录的核查表依从性高,但实际条目完成质量低。
  • 依从性数据不足以监测核查表质量。
  • 自下而上的实施策略可能提升核查表质量。

核心结论

  • 依从性数据不足以监测手术安全核查表的质量。
  • 通过自下而上的实施策略,使核查表更好地匹配现有流程和员工期望,可能提升其质量。

研究设计与样本

  • 解释性序贯混合方法研究,由2名培训观察员使用标准化工具记录51台儿科学术医院手术的核查表依从性和质量,随后访谈18名护士、麻醉科医生和外科医生。

主要发现

  • 医院记录的核查表依从性在简报、暂停和汇报阶段分别为94%、100%和100%,而匹配病例中实际完成的核查条目比例分别为26%、59%和42%。
  • 访谈主题分析提示,员工「买账」程度有限,源于核查表自上而下的强制性质、感知完成核查表缺乏益处以及与手术室其他流程的冗余。
  • 这导致手术安全核查表成为「打勾练习」,即记录依从性而未确保质量,从而掩盖了潜在的安全效益。

临床怎么用

  • 临床应关注核查表的实际完成质量,而非仅依赖依从性数据。
  • 可通过自下而上的实施策略,使核查表更好地校准现有流程和员工期望,以提升核查质量。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The surgical safety checklist is an evidence-based global initiative designed to reduce perioperative morbidity and mortality. However, the expounded benefits of the surgical safety checklist have not been realized in naturalistic settings. This may be related to the quality of surgical safety checklists being performed in operating rooms. METHODS: In this explanatory, sequential, mixed-methods study, 2 trained observers used a standardized tool to record the compliance and quality of the surgical safety checklist completed during 51 surgeries performed at a pediatric academic hospital. We compared compliance with each phase of the surgical safety checklist, the number of checklist items completed, and professionals initiating the surgical safety checklist across surgical specialties and case urgency levels. Interviews with nurses, anesthesiologists, and surgeons (n = 18) were subsequently conducted to explore and contextualize the findings. RESULTS: Hospital-recorded surgical safety checklist compliance (94%, 100%, and 100% on briefing, time out, and debriefing) was higher than the proportion of checklist items completed in matched cases (26%, 59%, and 42%, respectively). Thematic analysis of the interview data suggests this may result from limited staff "buy in," arising from the "top-down" mandated nature of the surgical safety checklist, the perceived lack of benefit in surgical safety checklist completion, and redundancies with other operating room processes. This has led to the surgical safety checklist becoming "an exercise in box ticking" (ie, compliance is recorded without ensuring quality), thereby obfuscating potential safety benefits. CONCLUSION: These results highlight that compliance data are insufficient for monitoring surgical safety checklist quality. Our study suggests that surgical safety checklist quality may be enhanced through better calibration of the surgical safety checklist with existing procedures and staff expectations through a bottom-up implementation strategy.

来源:Surgery,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Mahmood T, Mylopoulos M, Bagli D, et al. A mixed methods study of challenges in the implementation and use of the surgical safety checklist. Surgery. 2018. PMID: 30482388. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2018.09.012

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。