急诊普通外科结局的外科医生驱动变异:值班医生是谁重要吗?
基于佛罗里达州住院患者数据库(2010-2014)纳入2,149名外科医生、224家医院的569,767例急诊普通外科病例,采用多水平随机效应模型分析。结果显示外科医生层面变异对死亡率影响最大,解释32.77%的死亡风险总体变异,而并发症和再入院分别仅0.08%和2.28%。胃溃疡手术最易受外科医生变异影响,阑尾切除和胆囊切除最不易受影响。
要点
- 外科医生变异解释32.77%的死亡风险总体变异,远超并发症和再入院。
- 胃溃疡手术的死亡率和再入院最易受外科医生变异影响。
- 阑尾切除和胆囊切除在所有结局上最不易受外科医生变异影响。
核心结论
- 外科医生层面变异对急诊普通外科死亡率贡献显著,在高风险低频率手术中尤为明显。
- 减少急诊普通外科死亡率项目应关注降低高风险低频率手术的实践变异。
研究设计与样本
- 分析佛罗里达州住院患者数据库(2010-2014),链接美国医院协会年度调查数据库。
- 纳入急诊行7种手术之一的患者,共2,149名外科医生、224家医院、569,767例病例。
- 采用多水平随机效应模型量化归因于外科医生的死亡率、并发症和30天再入院变异。
主要发现
- 总体未调整死亡率为3.8%,并发症率和再入院率分别为12.7%和27.7%。
- 外科医生层面变异解释32.77%的死亡风险总体变异,并发症为0.08%,再入院为2.28%。
- 胃溃疡手术最易受外科医生层面死亡率和再入院变异影响,阑尾切除和胆囊切除最不易受影响。
临床怎么用
- 关注高风险低频率急诊手术(如胃溃疡手术)的外科医生实践变异。
- 减少急诊普通外科死亡率项目应重视降低实践变异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Hospital-level variation has been found to influence outcomes in emergency general surgery. However, whether the individual surgeon plays a role in this variation is unknown. METHODS: We performed an analysis of the Florida State Inpatient Database (2010-2014), which is linked to the American Hospital Association's Annual Survey Database, including patients who emergently underwent 1 or more of 7 procedures (laparotomy, adhesiolysis, small bowel resection, colectomy, repair of a perforated gastric ulcer, appendectomy, or cholecystectomy). We used multilevel random effects modeling to quantify the amount of variation in mortality, complications, and 30-day readmissions attributable to surgeons. Patient clinical and demographic factors, as well as hospital-level factors, were introduced into the model in a forward stepwise fashion, and the percent of the variation attributable to surgeons was derived. RESULTS: Our study included 2,149 surgeons across 224 hospitals, with a total of 569,767 emergency general surgery cases. The overall unadjusted mortality rate was 3.8%, and the complication and readmission rates were 12.7% and 27.7%, respectively. Surgeon-level variation had the greatest impact on mortality, explaining 32.77% of the overall variability in mortality risk compared with 0.08% and 2.28% for complications and readmissions, respectively. Peptic ulcer disease operations were most susceptible to surgeon-level variation in mortality and readmissions, whereas appendectomies and cholecystectomies were least susceptible to surgeon-level variation for all outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: Surgeon-level variation contributes to a significant portion of mortality in EGS. This variation is most pronounced in surgery for peptic ulcer disease, a high-risk, low-frequency surgical condition. Programs to reduce mortality in emergency general surgery should address reducing variability in practice with attention to high-risk, low-frequency procedures.
引用
- Udyavar R, Cornwell EE, Havens JM, et al. Surgeon-driven variability in emergency general surgery outcomes: Does it matter who is on call? Surgery. 2018. PMID: 30174142. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2018.07.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。