创伤与重症培训外科医生在常见急诊普外科疾病中的诊疗效率与成本比较
该研究比较了创伤与重症培训外科医生和其他普外科及亚专科医生在常见急诊普外科疾病中的诊疗效率。在急性阑尾炎和急性胆囊炎亚组中,手术室等待时间、住院时间和急诊费用均更优。
要点
- 创伤与重症培训外科医生接诊的急诊普外科患者从会诊到手术室时间更短。
- 急性阑尾炎和急性胆囊炎亚组中,创伤与重症培训外科医生接诊者住院时间和急诊费用更低。
- 两组在手术干预率、总住院时间和总费用上无显著差异。
核心结论
- 与普通外科及亚专科医生相比,创伤与重症培训外科医生对常见急诊普外科疾病提供更高效的诊疗,从会诊到手术室时间更短。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入2014年2月至2017年5月期间因急性阑尾炎、急性胆囊炎、肠梗阻、嵌顿疝或其他急性腹部诊断就诊于急诊普外科服务的成人患者,共1363例。
主要发现
- 共纳入1363例患者:急性阑尾炎384例(28.2%),急性胆囊炎477例(35.0%),肠梗阻406例(29.8%),嵌顿疝22例(1.6%),其他急性腹部诊断74例(5.4%)。
- 创伤与重症培训外科医生接诊836例(61.3%)患者。
- 两组手术干预率无差异,但创伤与重症培训外科医生接诊患者从会诊到手术室时间显著更短(7.0 vs 12.9小时;P < .001),住院时间和费用无差异。
- 急性阑尾炎和急性胆囊炎亚组中,创伤与重症培训外科医生接诊患者从会诊到手术室时间更短(8.4 vs 17.4小时;P < .001),住院时间更短(2.5 vs 2.8天;P = .021),急诊费用更低($822 vs $876;P = .012)。
临床怎么用
- 对于常见急诊普外科疾病,可考虑由创伤与重症培训外科医生接诊以缩短从会诊到手术室时间,尤其在急性阑尾炎和急性胆囊炎中可能降低住院时间和急诊费用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Our institutional emergency general surgery service is staffed by both trauma and critical care-trained surgeons and other boarded general surgeons and subspecialists. We compared efficiency of care for common emergency general surgery conditions between trauma and critical care-trained surgeons and boarded general surgeons and subspecialists. METHODS: Adults admitted between February 2014 and May 2017 with acute appendicitis, acute cholecystitis, intestinal obstruction, incarcerated hernia, or other acute abdominal diagnoses seen by emergency general surgery service were included. Demographic characteristics, consulting surgeon, operations, outcomes, and cost data were obtained. RESULTS: A total of 1,363 patients were included: 384 (28.2%) with acute appendicitis, 477 (35.0%) with acute cholecystitis, 406 (29.8%) with intestinal obstruction, 22 (1.6%) with incarcerated hernia, and 74 (5.4%) with other acute abdominal diagnoses. Trauma and critical care-trained surgeons saw 836 (61.3%) patients. There was no difference in operative management between the two groups, however, trauma and critical care-trained surgeons had significantly less time to the operative room (7.0 vs 12.9 hours; P < .001), without a difference in duration of stay or costs. The subgroups of acute appendicitis and acute cholecystitis when treated by trauma and critical care-trained surgeons had less time to the operative room (8.4 vs 17.4 hours; P < .001), shorter hospital stay (2.5 vs 2.8 days; P = .021), and less emergency department cost ($822 vs $876; P = .012). CONCLUSION: Compared with boarded general surgeons and subspecialists, trauma and critical care-trained surgeons provide more efficient care for common emergency general surgery conditions, with less time from consultation to the operative room.
引用
- Ladhani HA, Posillico SE, Zosa BM, et al. Efficiency of care and cost for common emergency general surgery conditions: Comparison by surgeon training and practice. Surgery. 2018. PMID: 30098814. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2018.05.048
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。