术后再入院与手术质量的关联:基于Delphi共识识别相关诊断编码
该改良Delphi共识由14名专家对2008至2014财年VA医疗中心住院手术后的30天再入院原因进行评估,判断其是否反映索引住院的手术质量。共识认定感染、脓毒症、肺炎、出血/血肿、贫血、造口并发症、急性肾衰竭、水电解质紊乱或静脉血栓栓塞等再入院与手术质量相关,占再入院的64%(25 521/39 664),占索引手术的7.5%(340 858例)。结论认为约三分之一术后再入院不太可能反映手术质量问题。
要点
- 感染、脓毒症、肺炎、出血/血肿等再入院被共识认为与手术质量相关。
- 上述相关再入院占再入院的64%,占索引手术的7.5%。
- 不同术式再入院与手术质量无关的比例从21%到47%不等。
核心结论
- 约三分之一术后再入院不太可能反映手术质量问题。
- 未来研究应测试将再入院限制于特定ICD-9编码是否可产生更有用的质量指标。
研究设计与样本
- 改良Delphi共识过程,由14名来自VA和私营机构的医疗与非医疗再入院专家参与。
- 共识过程于2017年1月至5月进行,数据于2017年6月分析。
主要发现
- 3轮Delphi后,14名专家对50个再入院原因达成共识;12名专家完成了第1轮和第2轮之间的电话会议。
- 感染、脓毒症、肺炎、出血/血肿、贫血、造口并发症、急性肾衰竭、水电解质紊乱或静脉血栓栓塞等再入院被认为与手术质量相关。
- 上述相关再入院占再入院的64%(25 521/39 664),占索引手术的7.5%(340 858例)。
- 与手术质量无关的再入院比例因术式而异,从下肢截肢后的21%(613/2331)到胆囊切除后的47%(745/1598)。
关键数值与推荐
- 专家对「再入院原因是否反映索引住院可能的手术质量 care 问题」按1(从不相关)至5(直接相关)评分。
- 共识认定与手术质量相关的再入院原因包括感染、脓毒症、肺炎、出血/血肿、贫血、造口并发症、急性肾衰竭、水电解质紊乱或静脉血栓栓塞。
临床怎么用
- 临床质量评价时可考虑将再入院区分为可能与手术质量相关和不相关两类。
- 感染、脓毒症、肺炎、出血/血肿等再入院原因可作为手术质量改进的监测重点。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Postoperative readmission data are used to measure hospital performance, yet the extent to which these readmissions reflect surgical quality is unknown. OBJECTIVE: To establish expert consensus on whether reasons for postoperative readmission are associated with the quality of surgery in the index admission. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: In a modified Delphi process, a panel of 14 experts in medical and surgical readmissions comprising physicians and nonphysicians from Veterans Affairs (VA) and private-sector institutions reviewed 30-day postoperative readmissions from fiscal years 2008 through 2014 associated with inpatient surgical procedures performed at a VA medical center between October 1, 2007, and September 30, 2014. The consensus process was conducted from January through May 2017. Reasons for readmission were grouped into categories based on International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision (ICD-9) diagnosis codes. Panelists were given the proportion of readmissions coded by each reason and median (interquartile range) days to readmission. They answered the question, "Does the readmission reason reflect possible surgical quality of care problems in the index admission?" on a scale of 1 (never related) to 5 (directly related) in 3 rounds of consensus building. The consensus process was completed in May 2017 and data were analyzed in June 2017. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Consensus on proportion of ICD-9-coded readmission reasons that reflected quality of surgical procedure. RESULTS: In 3 Delphi rounds, the 14 panelists achieved consensus on 50 reasons for readmission; 12 panelists also completed group telephone calls between rounds 1 and 2. Readmissions with diagnoses of infection, sepsis, pneumonia, hemorrhage/hematoma, anemia, ostomy complications, acute renal failure, fluid/electrolyte disorders, or venous thromboembolism were considered associated with surgical quality and accounted for 25 521 of 39 664 readmissions (64% of readmissions; 7.5% of 340 858 index surgical procedures). The proportion of readmissions considered to be not associated with surgical quality varied by procedure, ranging from to 21% (613 of 2331) of readmissions after lower-extremity amputations to 47% (745 of 1598) of readmissions after cholecystectomy. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: One-third of postoperative readmissions are unlikely to reflect problems with surgical quality. Future studies should test whether restricting readmissions to those with specific ICD-9 codes might yield a more useful quality measure.
引用
- Mull HJ, Graham LA, Morris MS, et al. Association of Postoperative Readmissions With Surgical Quality Using a Delphi Consensus Process to Identify Relevant Diagnosis Codes. JAMA Surg. 2018. PMID: 29710234. doi:10.1001/jamasurg.2018.0592
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。