文献速递胃肠外科肝胆胰外科

「手术量承诺」对胃肠肿瘤手术可及性与结局的潜在影响

Potential Impact of "Take the Volume Pledge" on Access and Outcomes for Gastrointestinal Cancer Surgery.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Surg · 2019-01-01

该研究基于美国国家癌症数据库(2006-2012)分析食管切除、直肠切除和胰腺切除医院,仅少数医院始终或间歇达到TVP年手术量阈值,多数患者在不达标医院接受手术;达标医院在肿瘤治疗流程和围术期结局上总体优于低量医院,但间歇低量、间歇高量与持续高量医院之间差异很少且不一致。

要点

  • 仅少数医院持续或间歇达到TVP年手术量阈值:食管切除1.6%、直肠切除19.7%、胰腺切除6.6%。
  • 多数食管切除(77.8%)、胰腺切除(53.4%)和近半直肠切除(48.1%)患者在不达标医院接受手术。
  • 达标医院结局总体优于低量医院,但各达标层级间差异少且不一致,区域化可能限制可及性。

核心结论

  • 若广泛实施TVP,仅少数医院能达到复杂肿瘤切除的年手术量阈值,且不同达标层级医院间结局差异很少且不一致。
  • 区域化政策可能有其价值,但若患者无法或不愿远行,可能损害患者自主性并限制医疗可及性。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于美国国家癌症数据库(2006-2012)的回顾性队列分析,纳入实施食管切除(n=968)、直肠切除(n=1250)或胰腺切除(n=1068)的医院。
  • 按医院达到TVP年手术量阈值的频率分为四类:始终低量(LV)、年均低量且间歇低量(ILV)、年均高量且间歇高量(IHV)、始终高量(HV)。
  • 采用多变量广义估计方程评估医院TVP分类与肿瘤治疗流程及围术期结局的关联。

主要发现

  • 达到TVP年手术量阈值(HV或IHV)的医院比例:食管切除1.6%、直肠切除19.7%、胰腺切除6.6%。
  • 在未达到TVP年手术量阈值(LV或ILV)的医院接受手术的患者比例:食管切除77.8%、胰腺切除53.4%、直肠切除48.1%。
  • 与LV医院相比,ILV、IHV和HV医院在三种手术的肿瘤治疗流程和围术期结局上总体更好,但ILV、IHV和HV医院之间差异很少且不一致。

关键数值与推荐

  • TVP年手术量阈值对应的医院达标比例:食管切除1.6%、直肠切除19.7%、胰腺切除6.6%。
  • 未达标医院(LV或ILV)承担的手术患者比例:食管切除77.8%、胰腺切除53.4%、直肠切除48.1%。

临床怎么用

  • 评估复杂肿瘤手术区域化政策时,需同时考虑达标医院比例低和多数患者在不达标医院就医的现实。
  • 临床转诊决策应权衡达标医院的结局优势与患者远行就医的可及性和自主性。
  • 不能仅凭TVP年手术量阈值简单判断医院质量,因各达标层级间结局差异不一致。

局限性

  • 原文摘要未报告本研究的具体局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To quantify the number of US hospitals that would meet "Take the Volume Pledge" (TVP) volume thresholds and compare outcomes at hospitals meeting and not meeting TVP thresholds. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: TVP aims to regionalize complex cancer resections to hospitals meeting established annual average volume thresholds. There is little data describing the potential impact on patient access if this initiative were broadly implemented or the relationship between these volume thresholds and quality of oncologic care. METHODS: Hospitals in the National Cancer Database (2006-2012) performing esophagectomy (n = 968), proctectomy (n = 1250), or pancreatectomy (n = 1068) were categorized based on frequency meeting TVP thresholds: always low volume (LV); low annual average and intermittently low volume (ILV); high annual average and intermittently high volume (IHV); always high volume (HV). Multivariable generalized estimating equations were used to evaluate the association between hospital TVP category, oncologic care processes, and perioperative outcomes. RESULTS: Few hospitals met annual TVP thresholds (HV or IHV)-esophagectomy 1.6%; proctectomy 19.7%; pancreatectomy 6.6%. The majority of esophagectomy (77.8%) and pancreatectomy (53.4%) and 48.1% of proctectomy patients received care at hospitals not meeting annual TVP thresholds (LV or ILV). While performance for all three procedures was generally better at ILV, IHV, and HV hospitals relative to LV hospitals, there were few differences (none of which were consistent) when comparing ILV, IHV, and HV hospitals to each other. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Few hospitals would meet TVP volume thresholds for complex cancer resections with little difference in outcomes between ILV, IHV, and HV hospitals. While a policy to regionalize complex surgical care may have merit, it could also compromise patient autonomy and limit access to care if patients are unable or unwilling to travel.

来源:Ann Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jacobs RC, Groth S, Farjah F, et al. Potential Impact of "Take the Volume Pledge" on Access and Outcomes for Gastrointestinal Cancer Surgery. Ann Surg. 2019. PMID: 29697444. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000002796

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。