外科试验中忽视聚类数据的系统综述与模拟研究
该系统综述评估腹股沟疝随机对照试验对聚类数据的处理情况,并用模拟比较不同统计方法。结果发现50项试验中仅24%在设计或分析中考虑聚类,忽视聚类可使I类错误率增加至12%并损失15%的检验效能。
要点
- 腹股沟疝试验中聚类数据常被忽视,仅24%在设计或分析中考虑。
- 忽视聚类可导致I类错误率升高至12%和检验效能损失至15%。
- 应依据随机化单位(患者或疝)在统计分析中处理聚类。
核心结论
- 腹股沟疝试验中聚类数据很少被考虑。
- 模拟表明忽视聚类可导致假阳性和假阴性结果,从而得出不恰当的研究结论。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索PubMed、Embase和Cochrane Library中2004至2013年发表的腹股沟疝随机对照试验。
- 纳入50项含双侧疝患者的试验,提取判断聚类数据处理是否恰当的研究特征。
- 模拟假设100个疝,比较考虑聚类与忽视聚类的统计方法。
主要发现
- 50项试验中20项(40%)未提供处理聚类数据的信息,18项(36%)按患者而非疝评估结局以回避聚类。
- 剩余12项试验(24%)均未在设计或分析中考虑聚类。
- 模拟中忽视聚类使I类错误率增加至12%,检验效能损失至15%,取决于随机化单位是患者还是疝。
临床怎么用
- 外科试验设计和分析时应考虑聚类数据,避免假阳性和假阴性结论。
- 若以患者为随机化单位,分析时应采用考虑聚类的统计方法。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Multiple surgical procedures in a single patient are relatively common and lead to dependent (clustered) data. This dependency needs to be accounted for in study design and data analysis. A systematic review was performed to assess how clustered data were handled in inguinal hernia trials. The impact of ignoring clustered data was estimated using simulations. METHODS: PubMed, Embase and the Cochrane Library were reviewed systematically for RCTs published between 2004 and 2013, including patients undergoing unilateral or bilateral inguinal hernia repair. Study characteristics determining the appropriateness of handling clustered data were extracted. Using simulations, various statistical methods accounting for clustered data were compared with an analysis ignoring clustering by assuming 100 hernias, with a varying percentage of patients having bilateral hernias. RESULTS: Of the 50 eligible trials including patients with bilateral hernias, 20 (40 per cent) did not provide information on how they dealt with clustered data and 18 (36 per cent) avoided clustering by assessing the outcome by patient and not by hernia. None of the remaining 12 trials (24 per cent) considered clustering in the design or analysis. In the simulations, ignoring clustering led to an increased type I error rate of up to 12 per cent and to a loss in power of up to 15 per cent, depending on whether the patient or the hernia was the randomization unit. CONCLUSION: Clustering was rarely considered in inguinal hernia trials. The simulations underline the importance of considering clustering as part of the statistical analysis to avoid false-positive and false-negative results, and hence inappropriate study conclusions.
引用
- Dell-Kuster S, Droeser RA, Schäfer J, et al. Systematic review and simulation study of ignoring clustered data in surgical trials. Br J Surg. 2018. PMID: 29405280. doi:10.1002/bjs.10763
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。