Medicare人群微创与开放手术的术后及经济结局比较
基于2014年Medicare住院数据集,纳入233,984例接受7种常见手术的患者,比较微创与开放手术的术后并发症、再入院、住院时长及费用。微创手术在多数术式中并发症和再入院更少、住院更短,部分术式费用更低。
要点
- 微创手术在5/7术式中并发症发生率更低(OR 0.36-0.69)。
- 微创手术在6/7术式中30天再入院率更低(OR 0.43-0.87)。
- 微创手术在6种术式中住院时长更短(缩短0.35-2.47天)。
核心结论
- 微创手术与更少并发症和再入院、更短住院时长及更低Medicare费用相关。
- 微创手术可能为Medicare人群提供更好的质量和成本效益。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,使用2014年Medicare Provider Analysis and Review住院有限数据集。
- 共纳入233,984例患者,其中开放手术102,729例,微创手术131,255例。
- 覆盖减重、胆囊切除、结肠切除、子宫切除、腹股沟疝、胸科及腹壁疝7种手术。
- 调整人口学特征和合并症后比较并发症 odds 和30天全因再入院 odds。
- 使用广义线性模型估算住院时长、Medicare索赔费用和报销的差异。
主要发现
- 微创手术并发症发生率在7种术式中的5种更低(OR 0.36-0.69)。
- 微创手术再入院率在7种术式中的6种更低(OR 0.43-0.87)。
- 微创手术住院时长在6种术式中更短(点估计范围缩短0.35-2.47天)。
- 微创手术Medicare索赔费用在4种术式中更低(每种手术少$3010.23-$4832.74)。
- 微创手术Medicare报销在3种术式中更低(每种手术少$841.10-$939.69)。
临床怎么用
- 在Medicare人群中,优先考虑微创手术可能降低并发症和再入院风险。
- 微创手术可缩短住院时长,并可能降低部分术式的费用和报销。
- 术式选择应结合具体手术类型评估微创获益。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Despite strong evidence demonstrating the clinical and economic benefits of minimally invasive surgery (MIS), utilization of MIS in the Medicare population is highly variable and tends to be lower than in the general population. We sought to compare the post-operative and economic outcomes of MIS versus open surgery for seven common surgical procedures in the Medicare population. METHODS: Using the 2014 Medicare Provider Analysis and Review Inpatient Limited Data Set, patients undergoing bariatric, cholecystectomy, colectomy, hysterectomy, inguinal hernia, thoracic, and ventral hernia procedures were identified using DRG and ICD-9 codes. Adjusting for patient demographics and comorbidities, the odds of complication and all-cause 30-day re-admission were compared among patients undergoing MIS versus open surgery stratified by operation type. A generalized linear model was used to calculate the estimated difference in length of stay (LOS), Medicare claim cost, and Medicare reimbursement. RESULTS: Among 233,984 patients, 102,729 patients underwent an open procedure versus 131,255 who underwent an MIS procedure. The incidence of complication after MIS was lower for 5 out of the 7 procedures examined (OR 0.36-0.69). Re-admission was lower for MIS for 6 out of 7 procedures (OR 0.43-0.87). MIS was associated with shorter LOS for 6 procedures (point estimate range 0.35-2.47 days shorter). Medicare claim costs for MIS were lower for 4 (range $3010.23-$4832.74 less per procedure) and Medicare reimbursements were lower for 3 (range $841.10-$939.69 less per procedure). CONCLUSIONS: MIS benefited Medicare patients undergoing a range of surgical procedures. MIS was associated with fewer complications and re-admissions as well as shorter LOS and lower Medicare costs and reimbursements versus open surgery. MIS may represent a better quality and cost proposition in the Medicare population.
引用
- Fan CJ, Chien HL, Weiss MJ, et al. Minimally invasive versus open surgery in the Medicare population: a comparison of post-operative and economic outcomes. Surg Endosc. 2018. PMID: 29484556. doi:10.1007/s00464-018-6126-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。