ACS NSQIP 单一 CPT 编码风险调整是否受同次麻醉多手术实践模式差异影响
该研究基于美国外科医师学会 NSQIP 数据库,比较仅用主要 CPT 编码与同时纳入风险最高附加 CPT 编码进行风险调整时医院比值比(OR)的差异。结果显示,在普外科死亡率与并发症模型以及乳房切除/重建模型中,两种调整方式所得医院 OR 基本一致;仅在子宫切除/妇科重建模型中,当医院 OR 和联合手术比例均较大时,单编码模型倾向轻度高估 OR。总体提示实践模式相关建模偏倚不常见且影响较小。
要点
- 普外科死亡率与并发症模型及乳房手术模型中,单编码与双编码风险调整的医院 OR 基本一致。
- 子宫切除/妇科重建模型中,当医院 OR 与联合手术比例均大时,单编码模型倾向轻度高估 OR。
- 在 ACS NSQIP 建模框架内,主要 CPT 编码对手术操作的风险调整基本充分。
核心结论
- 实践模式相关的建模偏倚在所考察领域不常见,对质量评估影响较小。
- 在 ACS NSQIP 建模范式内,主要 CPT 编码足以对手术操作进行风险调整。
研究设计与样本
- 基于美国外科医师学会 NSQIP 数据库的比较建模研究。
- 分别构建仅用主要 CPT 编码与同时纳入风险最高附加 CPT 编码的风险调整模型。
- 考察普外科死亡率与并发症模型,以及包含乳房切除/重建或子宫切除/妇科重建的数据集。
主要发现
- 普外科死亡率与并发症模型及乳房切除/重建模型中,两种编码策略的医院 OR 基本一致。
- 子宫切除/妇科重建模型中,当医院 OR 和联合手术比例均较大时,单编码模型倾向轻度高估 OR。
临床怎么用
- 在 ACS NSQIP 质量评估中,可沿用主要 CPT 编码进行手术操作风险调整。
- 对同次麻醉多手术比例高的医院,解读子宫切除/妇科重建相关 OR 时需留意可能的轻度高估。
局限性
- 研究仅覆盖所考察的普外科及乳房、妇科重建等特定数据集,未涉及所有手术领域。
- 原文未报告具体样本量、OR 数值、置信区间及 P 值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: American College of Surgeons NSQIP risk-adjustment models rely on the designated "principal" CPT code to account for procedure-related risk. However, if hospitals differ in their propensity to undertake multiple major operations under the same anesthetic, then risk adjustment using only a single code could bias hospital quality estimates. This study investigated this possibility for bias. STUDY DESIGN: We examined hospital odds ratios (ORs) when either the principal CPT code was used for risk adjustment (along with other standard NSQIP predictor variables) or when this code was used in addition to the remaining reported CPT code with the highest associated risk. We examined models for general surgery mortality and morbidity and morbidity in datasets that included mastectomy and/or breast reconstruction, or hysterectomy and/or gynecologic reconstruction as areas known to likely involve more than 1 procedure. RESULTS: Hospital ORs based on 1 vs 2 CPT codes for risk adjustment were essentially the same for mortality and morbidity general surgery models and for the mastectomy and/or breast reconstruction model. For hysterectomy and/or gynecologic reconstruction, the 1 CPT code model tended to slightly overestimate ORs compared with the 2 CPT codes model, when the hospital's OR and the proportion of combined operations were large. CONCLUSIONS: Conditions under which practice-pattern-associated modeling bias might exist appear to be uncommon and to have a small impact on quality assessments for the areas examined. The evidence suggests that, within the American College of Surgeons NSQIP modeling paradigm, the principal CPT code adequately risk adjusts for operative procedure in performance assessments.
引用
- Cohen ME, Liu Y, Liu JB, et al. Use of a Single CPT Code for Risk Adjustment in American College of Surgeons NSQIP Database: Is There Potential Bias with Practice-Pattern Differences in Multiple Procedures under the Same Anesthetic? J Am Coll Surg. 2018. PMID: 29309942. doi:10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2017.12.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。